B
Bret Cahill
Guest
And anyone who isn't careful could get electrocuted climbing into aThe issue is this, if you have grid tied power sources running in your
neighborhood, and they are producing power, anyone who isnt careful
doing electrical work could get electrocuted thinking that after they
pulled the main breaker, there is no power in the wires.
substation
What's your point?
Ignorant people might kill themselves doing something they weren't
properly trained to do?
Is this some kind of astounding new revelation?
I've got a lot of pull in Sweden. I'll personally see to it thatImagine if
you have a bunch of these pumping power into power poles laying on the
street after a storm; it becomes an instant fire starter.
anyone clever enough to solve this complicated problem will be getting
the very first Nobel in Electronics!
And there is less hope of changing electrical codes than getting theBut thats been taken care of too, because the DC to AC inverters
wont function due to this (also required by law and code) safety
feature built in.
pope to change his opinion on birth control!
The reason is simple. Electrical codes were written by and for
electricians who like to electrocute untrained scabs too cheap to do
things kosher.
Never mind most people sleep at night and only need a few hundredHeres the relevant code from the inverter
installation manual:
Electrical conformity according to U.S., Canadian and
international safety operating standards and code
requirements:
- UL 1741 Standard for Inverters, Converters, and
Controllers for Use in Independent Power Systems
And this:
4.2 Protective concepts
The following monitoring and protective functions are
integrated in blue planet inverters:
- BiSI grid monitoring to protect against personal
injuries and avoid islanding effects according to UL 1741
What is BiSI grid monitoring? According to E DIN VDE 0126, which is
a year 1999 standard developed in Europe specifically to address the
problem:
The automatic disconnection device is used as a safety interface
between the generator and the public low-voltage distribution net and
serves as a substitute for a disconnecting switch accessible at all
times by the distributing network operator. It prevents the
unintentional supply of electrical energy from the generator into a
subnetwork disconnected from the rest of the distribution grid
(islanding), thereby offering additional protection to the measures
specified in DIN VDE 0105-100 (VDE 0105-100), 6.2 to
- operating staff, against voltage in the disconnected subnetwork
- equipment, against inadmissible voltages and frequencies
- consumers, against inadmissible voltages and frequencies
- equipment, against the feed of faults by the generator.
In a nutshell, when the power poles go down, the inverters lose
connectivity to the grid, sense this automatically, and shut
themselves off.
Never mind the fact that grid-tied solar power doesnt work at night
when you need it most,
watts at night for the refrigerator and a few lights which is easily
supplied by a few deep cycle batteries.
Which lasts all of one or 2 days, not the week or so the power wasnever mind the fact that during and after the
storm, solar insolation is drastically reduced due to rain and
cloudiness,
out.
And it's not like anyone in electronics is smart enough to design anand never mind the fact that all electrical systems, solar
or otherwise, are just as susceptible to storm damage as conventional
power infrastructure, there is one important point that kills the
entire idea.
Assuming the solar panels arent ripped off the roof by the hurricane/
storm, they are of absolutely no use because the grid-tie is broken,
and the mandated grid-tie safety features prevent the homeowner from
using the inverters to get power locally.
over ride or bypass circuit.
Bret Cahill