J
Jon Slaughter
Guest
"krw" <krw@att.bizzzzzzzzzz> wrote in message
news:MPG.234c71f1de11c55b98a24d@news.individual.net...
voltage... that is only one concept in a huge number of concepts. Also we do
not know to what extent he didn't understand.
I can promise you that many EE graduates do not understand voltage but only
memorized formulas and defnitions..
So it isn't about what's right or wrong but what is real and not real. Sure
I would want everyone to have a little knowledge of everything... but that
isn't practical because then end up not being good at one thing
Did you ever stop to think that maybe the reason he didn't understand it was
that the professor that he took the class from that taught it didn't do a
good job? Do you also realize that there are many levels of understanding
it?
It's not that I don't agree with you that he should understand it and I'm
not even debating that.
But let me ask you something: Suppose he is the best bridge builder in the
world but he doesn't understand voltage... is it "ok"? Can we let it slide
or do we have to send the guy back to kindegarten to learn it? What if it
just can't do it and totally sucks at it? and he doesn't go around
pretending not too but just wants to build bridges... surely it's ok? It's
much better than 99% that don't know and don't give a shit about anything?
I think you guys are jumping to to many conclusions about the guy. We do not
know his circumstances and shouldn't judge him from one post on usenet that
says
"Hey, I'm in 3rd year mechanical engineering and I still don't feel
like I have a strong understanding of what voltage is. Maybe someone
can help explain the concept."
In fact the question's he asks are quite fair and natural and means he has
an inquisitive mind. So instead of judge him we should try to help him
understand. As long as he doesn't pretend to know something and long as he
doesn't put peoples life at risk then it's not a problem. Sure we can hope
he will understand everything the first time and learn everything he can but
this isn't a fairy tale.
news:MPG.234c71f1de11c55b98a24d@news.individual.net...
First off he's still in school... and second he said he didn't understandIn article <RfsEk.1952$ZP4.394@nlpi067.nbdc.sbc.com>,
Jon_Slaughter@Hotmail.com says...
"krw" <krw@att.bizzzzzzzzzz> wrote in message
news:MPG.234b62ace17ca7e698a24b@news.individual.net...
In article <gkhEk.2759$be.1230@nlpi061.nbdc.sbc.com>,
Jon_Slaughter@Hotmail.com says...
...
Nice job. Now he can go into fourth year.
No wonder our bridges are falling down.
When did one have to understand electricity to understand how to build
a
bridge?
Mechanical engineers don't build bridges either. They do build
automobiles and robots, though. Basic electricity would seem to be
a useful thing for MEs. Basic physics is rather useful, and
required, for EEs. MEs don't have to take the EM semester of
physics?
Ok... yes, I know that. Alhtough the overlap is much greater. Learning
about
your statics and dynamics is a major part of ME and CE'.
My response was specifically to the statement by Rose.
Understand. I was debating which one to respond to. ;-)
I'd rather the guy know squat about electricity and be a great bridge
builder than build shitty ass bridges cause he spent to much time
trying
to
learn about electricity for some school requirements to "broaden his
horizons". He could have spent that time more wisely.
Try a civil engineer if you want a bridge built. I'd rather my
civil engineer had the full load of physics too. We *are* talking
about basic electricity here.
Keith
True... but again, my statement was specifically about roses statement.
He/She is implying that if you don't know even the basics of electricity
then somehow you can't build a good bridge.
I don't think you should be an engineer without some knowledge of
basic physics. The fundamental units are rather important in all
engineering disciplines. I'm surely not an ME, but I know F=MA and
you can't push with a rope. ;-)
What I'm implying is that if the guy is an amazing bridge buildering(Ok,
I
know he's ME but Rose is the one who brought up the bridge building) then
it's ok for him to suck as EE.
"Suck as an EE" <> "sucks at fundamental physics"
I'm sure Tesla sucked at ice hockey but I don't see anyone complaining
that
he should have spent more time on it. (What does ice hockey have to do
with
EE? Who knows but thats not the point)
Understandable. I didn't learn any ice hockey in college physics
either.
Also we are getting off the point as if the guy is suppose to be the
best.
There are many EE's that don't even have a good understanding of their
own
craft so we should get onto those guys first.
The argument wasn't about whether or not there are EEs who shouldn't
be, rather whether it's understandable for an ME to lack basic
electrical knowledge. Would you think it OK for an EE to not know
that F=MA?
voltage... that is only one concept in a huge number of concepts. Also we do
not know to what extent he didn't understand.
I can promise you that many EE graduates do not understand voltage but only
memorized formulas and defnitions..
So it isn't about what's right or wrong but what is real and not real. Sure
I would want everyone to have a little knowledge of everything... but that
isn't practical because then end up not being good at one thing
Did you ever stop to think that maybe the reason he didn't understand it was
that the professor that he took the class from that taught it didn't do a
good job? Do you also realize that there are many levels of understanding
it?
It's not that I don't agree with you that he should understand it and I'm
not even debating that.
But let me ask you something: Suppose he is the best bridge builder in the
world but he doesn't understand voltage... is it "ok"? Can we let it slide
or do we have to send the guy back to kindegarten to learn it? What if it
just can't do it and totally sucks at it? and he doesn't go around
pretending not too but just wants to build bridges... surely it's ok? It's
much better than 99% that don't know and don't give a shit about anything?
I think you guys are jumping to to many conclusions about the guy. We do not
know his circumstances and shouldn't judge him from one post on usenet that
says
"Hey, I'm in 3rd year mechanical engineering and I still don't feel
like I have a strong understanding of what voltage is. Maybe someone
can help explain the concept."
In fact the question's he asks are quite fair and natural and means he has
an inquisitive mind. So instead of judge him we should try to help him
understand. As long as he doesn't pretend to know something and long as he
doesn't put peoples life at risk then it's not a problem. Sure we can hope
he will understand everything the first time and learn everything he can but
this isn't a fairy tale.