K
keith
Guest
On Mon, 06 Dec 2004 13:46:33 +0000, Bob Masta wrote:
It *may* have been easier to get accepted into ME than EE, and ChemE than
ME, but the selection was on entrance. Once one was *in* one could
transfer, but that took grades. Transferring in from another college was
almost impossible (it did happen, though only a few percent a year).
Once one was an EE, one could further specialize into
power/RF/microwave/digital/analog/computers/whatever. There were
advantages to having a large class (~450 EEs, IIRC). Even in the first
two years EEs took quite different courses than the rest.
--
Keith
WIWIES, people were accepted into the cirriculum they wanted, up front.On Mon, 06 Dec 2004 17:05:55 +1300, Terry Given <my_name@ieee.org
wrote:
I think the problem with mechanics is that it initially is more
accessible than electronics. By that I mean it is easy to get a handle
on say torque - lean on a bar, whereas getting a handle on an electron
is a bit trickier - you cant see it, feel it etc. most of the
electronics people I meet have a fair understanding of second order
systems, stuff like that. but few so-called mechanical engineers do. I
have been fortunate enough to work with some brilliant mechanical
engineers, people who are every bit as clever and creative as the
smartest electronics guys I know (some guys I very briefly worked with
at Penn State were incredible), but most seem a bit thick. Hell, try
getting a sheet metal shop to fold up a box accurately.
Then when you really get into it, mechanics is a lot more complex than
(most) electronics - nothing is isotropic, or homogeneous, or perhaps
even well characterised. Everything is as non-linear as all hell, and
the measurements are a lot harder. I suspect all the clever mech
engineers go work on the really tricky stuff, and leave the rest of the
work to the metal-shop dropouts.
When I was in engineering school, everyone took pretty much
the same core curriculum for the first 2 years. Then you got
to select whether you were going to be an EE, ME, or IE
(Industrial Engineer). The administration tried to steer you
into one of these based on your grade average: EE if you got
good grades, ME if mediocre, else IE. (With my average, I
had to *fight* for an EE slot!)
It *may* have been easier to get accepted into ME than EE, and ChemE than
ME, but the selection was on entrance. Once one was *in* one could
transfer, but that took grades. Transferring in from another college was
almost impossible (it did happen, though only a few percent a year).
Once one was an EE, one could further specialize into
power/RF/microwave/digital/analog/computers/whatever. There were
advantages to having a large class (~450 EEs, IIRC). Even in the first
two years EEs took quite different courses than the rest.
--
Keith