OT: Dimmable CFL

They should have said droop because of temperature rise.
You need proper design.

Its not mysterious.
The small leds as shown in the article are easy to overdrive
and get very fast droop, and then permanent droop.
They even change color as they start to burn up.
The specs don't usually say lm/watt
they give lumens at some wattage, usually 1.
If you decrease current, you get more lm/watt of course.
The article was specific about the conditions under which "droop" occurred,
and the fact that the cause is not understood.

This is interesting, because LEDs (red ones, at least) are generally more
efficient when pulsed at high currents.
 
On Thu, 01 Oct 2009 10:46:44 -0700, David Nebenzahl
<nobody@but.us.chickens>wrote:

On 9/30/2009 6:50 AM Meat Plow spake thus:

I see LED lighting being the next generation in home lighting and CFL
not lasting except in legacy application.

Maybe not: check out this article (this was posted in some newsgroup I
read or other, not sure if it was here):

http://www.spectrum.ieee.org/semiconductors/optoelectronics/the-leds-dark-secret

The LED's Dark Secret

Solid-state lighting won't supplant the lightbulb until it can
overcome the mysterious malady known as "droop"
Well I wonder why a lot of city and county road departments switching
to LED or installing new LED didn't hear about "the droop"?
 
On Thu, 1 Oct 2009 12:06:39 -0700, "William Sommerwerck"
<grizzledgeezer@comcast.net>wrote:

They should have said droop because of temperature rise.
You need proper design.

Its not mysterious.
The small leds as shown in the article are easy to overdrive
and get very fast droop, and then permanent droop.
They even change color as they start to burn up.
The specs don't usually say lm/watt
they give lumens at some wattage, usually 1.
If you decrease current, you get more lm/watt of course.

The article was specific about the conditions under which "droop" occurred,
and the fact that the cause is not understood.

This is interesting, because LEDs (red ones, at least) are generally more
efficient when pulsed at high currents.
I have a set of LED stage lights consisting of reg green and blue
LEDs. They're pretty bright and can take the place of smaller PAR
setups. The blue LEDs are not flashlight style blue but just plain
blue like in a primary color. When they are all on high intensity they
do all combine to form a white-ish light suitable for stage. And they
can be programmed to do all sorts of patterns. I doubt that this droop
is much of a consideration when you use three primary colors to make
white light. I do have some 3 watt flashlight LEDs and really haven't
notice any droop. The devices look like they are well built and
sinked.
 
I wonder why a lot of city and county road departments switching
to LED or installing new LED didn't hear about "the droop"?
Because they're not using blue LEDs.

Regardless, LEDs last much longer than incandescent lamps, and are
substantially more efficient, "droop" or not. So they come out ahead.
 
In article <ha36ap$8qk$1@news.eternal-september.org>,
William Sommerwerck <grizzledgeezer@comcast.net> wrote:
I wonder why a lot of city and county road departments switching
to LED or installing new LED didn't hear about "the droop"?

Because they're not using blue LEDs.

Regardless, LEDs last much longer than incandescent lamps, and are
substantially more efficient, "droop" or not. So they come out ahead.
Sadly I want decent quality light in my home. And no LED I've found yet
gives this. They can't seem to give a true daylight which would be fine
for some purposes - or a reasonable imitation of tungsten for that 'warm'
lighting when required.
Good quality fluorescent can though - but the choice of CFLs is too
limited at the moment to compete well with that.

--
*Gargling is a good way to see if your throat leaks.

Dave Plowman dave@davenoise.co.uk London SW
To e-mail, change noise into sound.
 
Sadly, I want decent quality light in my home. And no LED I've found yet
gives this. They can't seem to give a true daylight which would be fine
for some purposes -- or a reasonable imitation of tungsten for that "warm"
lighting when required.
No, not yet. Give 'em time.


Good quality fluorescent can, though -- but the choice of CFLs is too
limited at the moment to compete well with that.
I don't know. The $2 CFLs I get at Home Despot are terrific. The basic
balance is on the warm side, with no hint of blue or green. Though spec'd at
10K hours, they last about 2K. Which makes the purchase price no different
than incandescent lamps.

One way to get "warm" light is to use an appropriate shade. Three of mine
are mounted in Ikea glass "bullet" hanging fixtures, the fourth in Ikea's
cheap floor lamp. These shades add warmth. I also have two, without shades,
in the bath, on the "light bar" over the sink. Their unfiltered light is, to
my eyes, close to neutral, and definitely more pleasing the color of "warm"
conventional fluorescents in my kitchen.

Did I mention that they come on at more-than-useful brightness instantly,
and come to full brightness in about 30 seconds?

I don't know what everyone is complaining about. You can get really good,
cheap CFLs right now.

What more do you want?
 
In article <ha3htp$6i1$1@news.eternal-september.org>,
William Sommerwerck <grizzledgeezer@comcast.net> wrote:
Sadly, I want decent quality light in my home. And no LED I've found
yet gives this. They can't seem to give a true daylight which would be
fine for some purposes -- or a reasonable imitation of tungsten for
that "warm" lighting when required.

No, not yet. Give 'em time.
They've actually had quite a lot. Bit like batteries for cars - we're
still waiting for one which compares favourably to a tank of petrol, and
billions have been spent on research.


Good quality fluorescent can, though -- but the choice of CFLs is too
limited at the moment to compete well with that.

I don't know. The $2 CFLs I get at Home Despot are terrific. The basic
balance is on the warm side, with no hint of blue or green. Though
spec'd at 10K hours, they last about 2K. Which makes the purchase price
no different than incandescent lamps.
It's not so much the perceived colour, but more what its light does to
other colours like paint etc. Due to the spectrum being non continuous or
spikey. Of course tungsten alters colours too compared to daylight but in
a more subtle way.

One way to get "warm" light is to use an appropriate shade. Three of
mine are mounted in Ikea glass "bullet" hanging fixtures, the fourth in
Ikea's cheap floor lamp. These shades add warmth. I also have two,
without shades, in the bath, on the "light bar" over the sink. Their
unfiltered light is, to my eyes, close to neutral, and definitely more
pleasing the color of "warm" conventional fluorescents in my kitchen.
There is a vast range of fluorescents available - although not in all tube
sizes. The basic white and warm white are generally poor.

Did I mention that they come on at more-than-useful brightness instantly,
and come to full brightness in about 30 seconds?

I don't know what everyone is complaining about. You can get really good,
cheap CFLs right now.

What more do you want?
;-) At the moment I only use them for outdoor lighting and cupboards. The
latter because one of our energy companies supplied them free...

--
*I didn't drive my husband crazy -- I flew him there -- it was faster

Dave Plowman dave@davenoise.co.uk London SW
To e-mail, change noise into sound.
 
I don't know. The $2 CFLs I get at Home Despot are terrific.
The basic balance is on the warm side, with no hint of blue
or green. Though spec'd at 10K hours, they last about 2K.
Which makes the purchase price no different than
incandescent lamps.

It's not so much the perceived colour, but more what its light
does to other colours like paint etc. Due to the spectrum being
non-continuous or spikey. Of course tungsten alters colours,
too, compared to daylight but in a more subtle way.
I hope I don't sound unduly sarcastic when I ask... You're /that/ bothered
by metamerism?

I guess I'll have to photograph my Gretag-Macbeth chart under both the
cheapos (with and without shades) and the Lowell ego light (which is
supposed to give 90% "accurate" rendering), and see what happens. The latter
gives (to my eyes) essentially perfect rendition. (Yes, my monitor is
calibrated.)
 
In article <ha4qfj$3us$1@news.eternal-september.org>,
William Sommerwerck <grizzledgeezer@comcast.net> wrote:
It's not so much the perceived colour, but more what its light
does to other colours like paint etc. Due to the spectrum being
non-continuous or spikey. Of course tungsten alters colours,
too, compared to daylight but in a more subtle way.

I hope I don't sound unduly sarcastic when I ask... You're /that/
bothered by metamerism?
No - only if a colour I like changes into one I don't under artificial
light.

--
*Rehab is for quitters

Dave Plowman dave@davenoise.co.uk London SW
To e-mail, change noise into sound.
 

Welcome to EDABoard.com

Sponsor

Back
Top