Hardware book like "Code Complete"?

[Mike Treseler]

BobG wrote:

I read the whole thread and no one recommended "The Art Of Electronics"
by Horowitz and Hill??

That's more of an electronics book than an RTL book.

-- Mike Treseler

 

[Paul Floyd]

On Fri, 28 Jul 2006 11:33:25 -0700, Mike Treseler
<mike_treseler@comcast.net> wrote:

BobG wrote:
I read the whole thread and no one recommended "The Art Of Electronics"
by Horowitz and Hill??

That's more of an electronics book than an RTL book.

It _is_ an electronics book. There is one mention of RTL, but it's
'resistor-transistor logic'. Not quite the same thing.

A bientot
Paul
--
Paul Floyd http://paulf.free.fr (for what it's worth)
Surgery: ennobled Gerald.

 

[vijayvithal jahagirdar]

KJ wrote:

Many hands make light work. Get a couple of dozen of
experienced designers, a bunch of proof reading fact
checkers and one decent editor and you got yourself
an open source book writing project.

Put it out on sourceforge for free and make it useful for any
digital designer at any stage in their career or hobby.Do
a really good job and it can become the "bible" of the
industry that everyone has in the library.

Certainly an interesting idea.

Do we have the critical mass to pull something like this off?

Always a big question...the other important question is finding the
'leader' to prod this along to get it going in the first place.

KJ
A few months ago a similar Idea was posted on an ASIC and Digital

design community at Orkut. The basic Idea was
a) To collect class notes/Presentation on a particular topic and expand
it to a book or
b) A person will come up with the book outline and others will submit
articles on specific topics and flesh it out
The final goal being to get a set of books on hardware design. You can
check the details at http://edaindia.com/books/

Regards
H.H.I Tracy
.....

 

[David Ashley]

vijayvithal jahagirdar wrote:

A few months ago a similar Idea was posted on an ASIC and Digital
design community at Orkut. The basic Idea was
a) To collect class notes/Presentation on a particular topic and expand
it to a book or
b) A person will come up with the book outline and others will submit
articles on specific topics and flesh it out
The final goal being to get a set of books on hardware design. You can
check the details at http://edaindia.com/books/

Regards
H.H.I Tracy

Why not go with Wikipedia? It's so easy for anyone to add to.
Just host the wikipedia software on some other server, if
Wikipedia's policies aren't satisfactory.

-Dave

 

[Colin Marquardt]

David Ashley <dash@nowhere.net.dont.email.me> writes:

vijayvithal jahagirdar wrote:
A few months ago a similar Idea was posted on an ASIC and Digital
design community at Orkut. The basic Idea was
a) To collect class notes/Presentation on a particular topic and expand
it to a book or
b) A person will come up with the book outline and others will submit
articles on specific topics and flesh it out
The final goal being to get a set of books on hardware design. You can
check the details at http://edaindia.com/books/

Why not go with Wikipedia? It's so easy for anyone to add to.
Just host the wikipedia software on some other server, if
Wikipedia's policies aren't satisfactory.

One could use http://wikibooks.org or http://wikia.com/ for hosting.
I too think that such a book project is doomed if the hurdle for
contributing is too high.

Cheers,
Colin

 

[vijay]

Colin Marquardt wrote:

David Ashley <dash@nowhere.net.dont.email.me> writes:

Why not go with Wikipedia? It's so easy for anyone to add to.
Just host the wikipedia software on some other server, if
Wikipedia's policies aren't satisfactory.

One could use http://wikibooks.org or http://wikia.com/ for hosting.
I too think that such a book project is doomed if the hurdle for
contributing is too high.

Cheers,
Colin

Most of the contributors to this thread seem to agree that writing a
Speciality book does not justify the effort that needs to be put in.
The reasons stated are
1> Small number of Digital designers.
2> Long time required to finish writing the book.

As an example suppose I decide to write a document on "VHDL/Verilog
coding style for Low Power mixed signal designs" which basically
collates the various material available on this topic in Public domain
and presents it in an easy to read and implement format. Out of the
estimated 10,000 Digital design engineers only a couple of hundreds
engineers (for e.g. those working on chips for handheld applications)
will actually find the book useful to the work at hand and will be
actually interested in buying the book. This makes the effort put in
writing the book commerically unviable.

Now suppose as a part of my normal work(either academic or otherwise) I
come up with a similar document which my funding organisation allows me
to put in public domain. I would rather prefer to put it as
is(ppt,word,pdf,ps,html etc.) and move on to the next pending work,
rather than rewrite the document in the format required by wiki.

I think in such a situation one of the following approach may be
suitable
1> Upload the document to my personal website and post the url to
usenet and other forums.
2> Upload the document to a common repository(Some place for electronic
documents similar to what CPAN is for Perl code or CTAN for tex macros)
say a sharepoint or a twiki or an interface similar to CPAN.

Collecting a set of similar articles, say on the topic of "digital
design in a low power mixed signal design" written by different authors
would give those 200 engineers working in this field a standard
reference. Due to the different formats and writing styles it would not
be a proper book but it can act as a loosely bound reference material

At a later date if this does turn out to be a hot topic and a demand
exists for a published text then it should be possible to get the
proper permissions form the respective authors and cleanup the
formatting linearise the content and publish the book.

Regards
Vijay

 

[larwe]

Andy Glew wrote:

Care to estimate the size of the market?

I.e. how much would the author expect to make, given typical publishing contracts?

Speaking as someone who's written three speciality-ish engineering
books (go to www.larwe.com and look down the left-hand column for links
to the books), the point of writing a volume like this is one of two
things:

1. Get it picked up as a textbook or training book in college or by one
of the major semi manufacturers.

2. Treat it as advertising.

Route 1 can lead to respectable direct profits. Route 2 leads to
indirect profits through consultancy and so forth. Do not expect to
make your fortune through route 1; the real money is in route 2 but
requires more work to realize.

Your book is the dynamite that exposes a seam of gold. Significant
pick-work is necessary to extract the gold and bring it to town for
conversion into cash.

 

[Tom Lucas]

"larwe" <zwsdotcom@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:1156102639.513866.80000@i3g2000cwc.googlegroups.com...

Andy Glew wrote:

Care to estimate the size of the market?

I.e. how much would the author expect to make, given typical
publishing contracts?

Speaking as someone who's written three speciality-ish engineering
books (go to www.larwe.com and look down the left-hand column for
links
to the books), the point of writing a volume like this is one of two
things:

1. Get it picked up as a textbook or training book in college or by
one
of the major semi manufacturers.

2. Treat it as advertising.

Route 1 can lead to respectable direct profits. Route 2 leads to
indirect profits through consultancy and so forth. Do not expect to
make your fortune through route 1; the real money is in route 2 but
requires more work to realize.

Your book is the dynamite that exposes a seam of gold. Significant
pick-work is necessary to extract the gold and bring it to town for
conversion into cash.

Must it always be about the money? Won't somebody think of the children
;-)