Followup on PC built outside the case

[Bob Villa]

On Mar 25, 1:20 am, D <n...@hotmail.com> wrote:

Your approach makes a lot of sense.  I had an AMD Athlon awhile back,
the last pre-build PC I've bought (Gateway.  They still in business?
;-), it was fine, once I got rid of that abysmal Win ME & replaced it
with Win 2K.

Gateway (and eMachines) are owned by Acer.

 

[JW]

On Thu, 24 Mar 2011 14:21:38 -0700 D <none@hotmail.com> wrote in Message
id: <4d8bb5dd$0$3362$c3e8da3$9b4ff22a@news.astraweb.com>:

On 3/24/2011 6:54 AM, JW wrote:

There was a 'sort-of' recall on i7 chips a while back. Google i7 SATA
bug.

I think that was the Q57 chipset, not the processor, though.

Is this the recall in question: http://techreport.com/discussions.x/20326 ?

The page says in part:

The problem that's caused Intel to initiate a billion-dollar chipset
recall affects the SATA ports on all 6-series chipsets, including the
H67 and P67 chipsets most prominently used in consumer products. All of
these chipsets are collectively referred to as "Cougar Point" inside of
Intel. Because there are no third-party chipsets compatible with Sandy
Bridge processors, all Sandy Bridge-based systems are potentially
affected, including desktops, laptops, and DIY motherboards.

My bad. I didn't check my facts before posting and was going from memory.
That's the bug I was referring to.

I'm assuming that since my MOBO is a GIGABYTE GA-X58A-UD3R LGA 1366
Intel X58 SATA 6Gb/s USB 3.0 ATX, which (apparently) uses the X58
chipset, not the H67 or the P67, that this is not an issue for me, correct?

Correct.

 

[William Sommerwerck]

My gut feeling is that when you get it in a case,
properly grounded and cooled, it will be fine.

Ditto. I've seen this with other products. They fail to work correctly
outside the case or cabinet, for no obvious reason, but (after hours of
frustrating troubleshooting) they work correctly when put back.

 

[Meat Plow]

On Thu, 24 Mar 2011 20:36:26 -0700, stratus46 wrote:

On Mar 24, 4:35 pm, D <n...@hotmail.com> wrote:

No problem ;-)  This is my 2nd "new build", I've found there's such
a
bewildering array of mobos, etc., that I tend to just go for
something
that's sort of on the "bottom rung of the top tier", so to speak,
that
way I seem to get near-state of the art performance, without
spending
the absolute max, and also without having to spend eons studying
each
available option.  Kinda like buying the cheapest house in an
expensive
neighborhood...  ;-)

And I take different approach. AMD Phenom II processors on Gigabyte 780
series boards. According to the benchmarks, the AMD gets 70-90% of the
performance of the Intels and usually comes in at about 1/4 the price.
The 3 of them together ran about $1400 total, each with 4 gigs, at least
2TB worth of drives (1.5T + 500G) and an HDTV tuner each. Next machine
will likely be another Gigabyte board, probably an 880 series, certainly
with integrated graphics and another AMD. If I get burned by the
Gigabyte boards I'll look at Asus and Tyan but won't use any more ECS,
Biostar or MSI boards. So far I have 5 Gigabyte machines and another at
work and no problems with any of them.

For those who are leery of AMD, the Harris servers used at at least 2 of
the major TV networks (CBS and Fox) deliver all your TV with AMD
processors.

G²

PhenomII 955 on Asus M4A78T-E o'clocked to 4 ghz. Not a single problem.

I for one haven't paid for an Intel platform since 2000.



--
Live Fast Die Young, Leave A Pretty Corpse

 

[Meat Plow]

On Fri, 25 Mar 2011 06:07:13 -0700, William Sommerwerck wrote:

My gut feeling is that when you get it in a case, properly grounded and
cooled, it will be fine.

Ditto. I've seen this with other products. They fail to work correctly
outside the case or cabinet, for no obvious reason, but (after hours of
frustrating troubleshooting) they work correctly when put back.

That would be my advice also. Get it mounted proper in a case and see
what happens. Not only the proper grounding but the proper airflow over
the devices.



--
Live Fast Die Young, Leave A Pretty Corpse

 

[D]

On 3/25/2011 9:08 AM, Meat Plow wrote:

On Fri, 25 Mar 2011 06:07:13 -0700, William Sommerwerck wrote:

My gut feeling is that when you get it in a case, properly grounded and
cooled, it will be fine.

Ditto. I've seen this with other products. They fail to work correctly
outside the case or cabinet, for no obvious reason, but (after hours of
frustrating troubleshooting) they work correctly when put back.

That would be my advice also. Get it mounted proper in a case and see
what happens. Not only the proper grounding but the proper airflow over
the devices.

Thanks for the continued input everyone. Most recent developments: I
again tried the Win 7 on my new SATA, but with a known-good PSU, and it
froze in about 15 minutes. So it's not the PSU. After this, I loaded a
32 bit copy of XP Pro on an IDE drive, and the machine has run for about
4 hours without a freeze (I should add I loaded Win 7 previously on this
same drive, and it froze like it did on the SATA). During the time the
machine has been running fine under XP Pro, the PC has been surfing the
internet on one monitor, while continuously playing .VOB videos on VLC
with the audio muted on a remote plasma (like the older build this one
is to replace, I use the computer for general PC use as well as for a
HTPC), while also playing a 2 hour MP3 on Winamp. One possible
conclusion from this that either the PC, or the video card, does not
like 64 bits. Reading the reviews of the board on Newegg, many people
seem to be running Win 7 64 bit with no problem, so I'm guessing it's
not that the MOBO has a problem with that OS. Am I correct that it would
be unlikely for either the RAM or the CPU to be intolerant of 64 bit Win 7?

BTW, ran Memtest for ~ 3 hours. No errors.

I'm considering replacing the vid card, since it seems a very likely
suspect. I'm not a gamer (though this gear should be up to it), so I
don't need anything tooooo drastic (read, EXPENSIVE). As JL suggested,
I'm wondering about the PCI E 2.0 slots. Also, I've been using a X16
slot (MOBO also has X8 slots). Could the Vid card be the culprit? And
opinions on this card for my applications:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814131350

Thanks again for the replies!

Dan

 

[KR]

On Mar 24, 7:17 pm, D <n...@hotmail.com> wrote:

I've put the computer together which I mentioned in my previous "outside
the case" post, and I'm am having a bit of difficulty, though I doubt
it's related to the no-case part.  I know this isn't really a computer
forum, but if any of the very knowledgeable people here have any
insights into the following, I'd sure appreciate hearing them.

The components of the new build are as follows:

-GIGABYTE GA-X58A-UD3R LGA 1366 Intel X58 SATA 6Gb/s USB 3.0 ATX Intel
Motherboard

-Intel Core i7-950 Bloomfield 3.06GHz LGA 1366 130W Quad-Core Processor
BX80601950

-HITACHI Deskstar 5K3000 HDS5C3020ALA632 (0F12117) 2TB SATA 6.0Gb/s 3.5"
Internal Hard Drive -Bare Drive

-CORSAIR XMS3 6GB (3 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR3 SDRAM DDR3 1333 (PC3 10666)
Triple Channel Kit Desktop Memory Model TR3X6G1333C9

-Microsoft Windows 7 Home Premium 64-bit 1-Pack for System Builders - OEM

-Thermaltake Black Widow PSU W0319RU 850W ATX 12V v2.3, EPS 12V v2.91
CrossFire Certified 80 PLUS BRONZE

-Older Powercolor X800 GTO vid card

I have initially set up the bits on a table, outside of the case (so I
can still use the PC which is now occupying the case until all is well
with the new bits). Loading went fine, got online & began loading
software, when the PC locked up. In the ~6 hours I've been playing with
this, it has not run longer than about 20 minutes without locking up,
sometimes only 5 or 10 minutes. It seems fine, then just locks. No
mouse, no keyboard, no ctrl/alt/del function, I have to do a reset to
get it going again. I've pulled the HDD & re-installed the OS on a spare
160 gig IDE drive I have, same behavior, so it's not the HDD. What
components are the most likely culprits here? Any suggestions anyone
might have on this situation would be greatly appreciated!

I should add that I installed about 55 updates from MS to the Win 7
installation (all available), after which it still locked.

Haven't had an OS lock up since Windows ME. I'm already missing XP! ;-(

Dan

I have had to assemble PC's some years back for applications where a
normal case couldnt be used. One thing that was noticed was the
amount of heat on the backing plate that the motherboard was mounted
onto. This led me to believe that the metal PCB standoffs and backing
plate play an important role in passing heat from the motherboard to
the backing plate (as well as providing a gap for air circulation
underneath. They may also help greatly in providing a very solid
earth connection as well.

 

[William Sommerwerck]

BTW, ran Memtest for ~3 hours. No errors.

I know from experience that memory test programs do not always find bad RAM.

I'm considering replacing the video card, since it seems
a likely suspect.

If the card works under multiple operating systems, that pretty much rules
out the card. However, you might have problems with the driver.

One of the good things about cards using Nvidia chips is that they'll run
with "generic" drivers written by Nvidia. (This is also probably true of the
other major brand, whose name I can't think of). Try using one of these.

 

[Meat Plow]

On Fri, 25 Mar 2011 23:01:09 -0700, D wrote:

On 3/25/2011 9:08 AM, Meat Plow wrote:
On Fri, 25 Mar 2011 06:07:13 -0700, William Sommerwerck wrote:

My gut feeling is that when you get it in a case, properly grounded
and cooled, it will be fine.

Ditto. I've seen this with other products. They fail to work correctly
outside the case or cabinet, for no obvious reason, but (after hours
of frustrating troubleshooting) they work correctly when put back.

That would be my advice also. Get it mounted proper in a case and see
what happens. Not only the proper grounding but the proper airflow over
the devices.




Thanks for the continued input everyone. Most recent developments: I
again tried the Win 7 on my new SATA, but with a known-good PSU, and it
froze in about 15 minutes. So it's not the PSU. After this, I loaded a
32 bit copy of XP Pro on an IDE drive, and the machine has run for about
4 hours without a freeze (I should add I loaded Win 7 previously on this
same drive, and it froze like it did on the SATA). During the time the
machine has been running fine under XP Pro, the PC has been surfing the
internet on one monitor, while continuously playing .VOB videos on VLC
with the audio muted on a remote plasma (like the older build this one
is to replace, I use the computer for general PC use as well as for a
HTPC), while also playing a 2 hour MP3 on Winamp. One possible
conclusion from this that either the PC, or the video card, does not
like 64 bits. Reading the reviews of the board on Newegg, many people
seem to be running Win 7 64 bit with no problem, so I'm guessing it's
not that the MOBO has a problem with that OS. Am I correct that it would
be unlikely for either the RAM or the CPU to be intolerant of 64 bit Win
7?

BTW, ran Memtest for ~ 3 hours. No errors.

I'm considering replacing the vid card, since it seems a very likely
suspect. I'm not a gamer (though this gear should be up to it), so I
don't need anything tooooo drastic (read, EXPENSIVE). As JL suggested,
I'm wondering about the PCI E 2.0 slots. Also, I've been using a X16
slot (MOBO also has X8 slots). Could the Vid card be the culprit? And
opinions on this card for my applications:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814131350

Thanks again for the replies!

Dan

Look for an EVGA branded GeForce 9500 series.



--
Live Fast Die Young, Leave A Pretty Corpse

 

[chuck]

On Fri, 25 Mar 2011 23:01:09 -0700, D <none@hotmail.com> wrote:

On 3/25/2011 9:08 AM, Meat Plow wrote:
On Fri, 25 Mar 2011 06:07:13 -0700, William Sommerwerck wrote:

My gut feeling is that when you get it in a case, properly grounded and
cooled, it will be fine.

Ditto. I've seen this with other products. They fail to work correctly
outside the case or cabinet, for no obvious reason, but (after hours of
frustrating troubleshooting) they work correctly when put back.

That would be my advice also. Get it mounted proper in a case and see
what happens. Not only the proper grounding but the proper airflow over
the devices.




Thanks for the continued input everyone. Most recent developments: I
again tried the Win 7 on my new SATA, but with a known-good PSU, and it
froze in about 15 minutes. So it's not the PSU. After this, I loaded a
32 bit copy of XP Pro on an IDE drive, and the machine has run for about
4 hours without a freeze (I should add I loaded Win 7 previously on this
same drive, and it froze like it did on the SATA). During the time the
machine has been running fine under XP Pro, the PC has been surfing the
internet on one monitor, while continuously playing .VOB videos on VLC
with the audio muted on a remote plasma (like the older build this one
is to replace, I use the computer for general PC use as well as for a
HTPC), while also playing a 2 hour MP3 on Winamp. One possible
conclusion from this that either the PC, or the video card, does not
like 64 bits. Reading the reviews of the board on Newegg, many people
seem to be running Win 7 64 bit with no problem, so I'm guessing it's
not that the MOBO has a problem with that OS. Am I correct that it would
be unlikely for either the RAM or the CPU to be intolerant of 64 bit Win 7?

BTW, ran Memtest for ~ 3 hours. No errors.

I'm considering replacing the vid card, since it seems a very likely
suspect. I'm not a gamer (though this gear should be up to it), so I
don't need anything tooooo drastic (read, EXPENSIVE). As JL suggested,
I'm wondering about the PCI E 2.0 slots. Also, I've been using a X16
slot (MOBO also has X8 slots). Could the Vid card be the culprit? And
opinions on this card for my applications:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814131350

Thanks again for the replies!

Dan

On the Dell that I previously mentioned, playing Winamp while using IE
results in a blue screen within a 1/2 hour . On Friday I updated all
drivers and firmware and ran Dell's self diagnostics; still computer
blue screens when using Winamp. It also crashes when streaming audio
using Real Player though it might take an hour or so. Chuck