J
Joel Koltner
Guest
<alertjean@rediffmail.com> wrote in message
news:98e3f191-fdd5-4ee2-900d-347854303bf4@j12g2000vbl.googlegroups.com...
"Dave..You are smart..It was an exam question. But I am not convinced
by the answer professor gave me...that FPGAs will takeover standard
cell designs thereby reducing the number of standard cell designs. I
think as the performance and power of FPGAs will be bad compared to SC
designs, SC designs are always going to be winners
and I dont think FPGAs will take over."
The problem is that it isn't defined exactly what "take over" here means. You
and the professor are both right -- FPGAs are definitely replacing what would
have previously been standard cell designers more and more every year, but in
some applications power and performance (or at least performance per dollar)
are critical and FPGAs are unlikely to be competitive -- ever: Such designs
will not be "taken over."
What kind of professor puts, "Do you believe..." questions on an engineering
exam anyway? He might as well have asked you if you believe in
anthropomorphic global warming or the tooth fairy.
news:98e3f191-fdd5-4ee2-900d-347854303bf4@j12g2000vbl.googlegroups.com...
"Dave..You are smart..It was an exam question. But I am not convinced
by the answer professor gave me...that FPGAs will takeover standard
cell designs thereby reducing the number of standard cell designs. I
think as the performance and power of FPGAs will be bad compared to SC
designs, SC designs are always going to be winners
and I dont think FPGAs will take over."
The problem is that it isn't defined exactly what "take over" here means. You
and the professor are both right -- FPGAs are definitely replacing what would
have previously been standard cell designers more and more every year, but in
some applications power and performance (or at least performance per dollar)
are critical and FPGAs are unlikely to be competitive -- ever: Such designs
will not be "taken over."
What kind of professor puts, "Do you believe..." questions on an engineering
exam anyway? He might as well have asked you if you believe in
anthropomorphic global warming or the tooth fairy.