Ask about finding maximum and second's maximum number in arr

[phanhuyich]

I am starting to study VHDL. Now, I have to do an exercise with the following content:

I have to define an array of 10 elements ( 8 bit range) ([3,4,2,8,9,0,1,5,7,6] for example). And 10 elements were imported to within 10 clock cycles. The question is find the maximum number and second maximum number in this array after 10 clock cycle.
Anyone help to show me the method to solve it using VHDL ?

Thank you.

 

[valtih1978]

Here is the computation of the max

process
variable max: integer := Integer.Minimum;
begin
for I in 1 to 10 loop
wait until clk = '1';
if (input > max)
max := input;
end if;
end loop;
report "max = " & integer'image(max);
end process;

I am sure, you can extend it to the pre-max variable by something like
if (input > max)
premax := max;
max := input;
end if;

 

[Andy]

Your premax solution only works if the highest value occurs in the input stream after the 2nd highest value, and the 2nd highest value does not have the same value as the highest value.

You need a separate comparison of input and premax. That means premax needs initialization too.

Process variables are only initialized at time zero; when the implied process loop (not the loop statement) repeats, the variable is not re-initialized.

In all fairness though, the OP did not state he needed a synthesizable solution.

Andy

 

[Anssi Saari]

Andy <jonesandy@comcast.net> writes:

Your premax solution only works if the highest value occurs in the input stream after the 2nd highest value, and the 2nd highest value does not have the same value as the highest value.

You need a separate comparison of input and premax. That means premax needs initialization too.

Process variables are only initialized at time zero; when the implied process loop (not the loop statement) repeats, the variable is not re-initialized.

In all fairness though, the OP did not state he needed a synthesizable solution.

Didn't he mention a clock cycle limit of 10 though? So it slightly hints
towards synthesizable. Or at least synchronous.

Another solution is of course sorting the array and taking the two
largest values. I'd do that if this were a real problem and there were
some doubt that maybe it's not the two largest but perhaps the fourth or
seventh largest value I need... Or the median for that matter.

 

[Andy]

The OP said; "And 10 elements were imported to within 10 clock cycles". That is not the same as "only 10 clocks will be provided".

What does the model do on the 11th and following clock cycles?

Andy