C
Commander Kinsey
Guest
On Sun, 29 May 2022 01:35:23 +0100, ke...@kjwdesigns.com <keith@kjwdesigns.com> wrote:
Tell that to Rochard Hammond.
They used to be cheap until cars started using them, now I have to pay three times as much to power my fucking torch.
> Larger format cells have the potential advantage of less material used to package the cell with a possibility of improving energy to weight ratio.
Until something better than Lithium Ion is invented, they just aren\'t powerful enough for a car. Lithium is for laptops, or maybe a golf cart.
> Tesla cells have gradually been increasing in size while keeping a similar style. The original 18650 has progressed to 2170 and next to 4680. The cell numbering system is the diameter in mm followed by the height in tenths of a mm so an 18650 is 18mm die by 65.0mm tall.
Which would make a 2170 only 21mm wide and 7mm tall. So a coin cell?
> WIth these changes (and others) Tesla claims to have improved cost, energy density and power density and as well as reductions in use of raw materials while expecting greatly improved lifetime.
And yet they still rip people off with absurdly expensive cars much like Apple rip off people with their overpriced computers. One born every minute.
On Saturday, 28 May 2022 at 16:49:59 UTC-7, Commander Kinsey wrote:
On Sun, 29 May 2022 00:02:26 +0100, ke...@kjwdesigns.com <ke...@kjwdesigns.com> wrote:
On Saturday, 28 May 2022 at 15:46:31 UTC-7, Commander Kinsey wrote:
On Tue, 17 May 2022 20:23:09 +0100, Ed Lee <edward....@gmail.com> wrote:
On Tuesday, May 17, 2022 at 12:10:26 PM UTC-7, John Doe wrote:
Using a jillion tiny cells makes a difference because if any of those cells
fail, the whole car explodes and kills the driver.
Then the BMS is not doing it\'s job. Proper BMS should monitor each cell and alarm if they overheat.
Which means lots of tiny cells means more monitoring.
No. A group of about 30-40 cells are connected in parallel. They are then monitored as if they were single larger cell as they all have the same voltage.
So one of those 30-40 cells shorts out, then what? It\'s getting fucking hot with the other 29-39 cells rapidly charging it, and there\'s no sensor on it? The other 29-39 look just fine, all is well, oops driver dead in a fireball.
In the case of Tesla they implement the bond wire from the cell to the common connection asa fusible link to protect against that eventuality.
I expect Rivian has a similar feature.
What actually happens is that most shorting failures occur within the body of the cell and the short itself gets cleared in a similar fashion to what happens in plastic film capacitors when a breakdown occurs. This would also apply to larger format cells.
Tell that to Rochard Hammond.
Only Tesla and Rivian use small cells. All other EV manufacturers uses large cells typically of 20Ah to 60Ah.
Why this difference between manufacturers?
Each manufacturer has their own ideas about how to optimize cost, space, weight etc.
Tesla started out by exploiting the fact that 18650 cells were the most common mass production cells. The manufacturing processes and equipment were optimized to make those at lowest cost.
They used to be cheap until cars started using them, now I have to pay three times as much to power my fucking torch.
> Larger format cells have the potential advantage of less material used to package the cell with a possibility of improving energy to weight ratio.
Until something better than Lithium Ion is invented, they just aren\'t powerful enough for a car. Lithium is for laptops, or maybe a golf cart.
> Tesla cells have gradually been increasing in size while keeping a similar style. The original 18650 has progressed to 2170 and next to 4680. The cell numbering system is the diameter in mm followed by the height in tenths of a mm so an 18650 is 18mm die by 65.0mm tall.
Which would make a 2170 only 21mm wide and 7mm tall. So a coin cell?
> WIth these changes (and others) Tesla claims to have improved cost, energy density and power density and as well as reductions in use of raw materials while expecting greatly improved lifetime.
And yet they still rip people off with absurdly expensive cars much like Apple rip off people with their overpriced computers. One born every minute.