Poor practice, but does it create a voltage error?...

[Lamont Cranston]

Measuring Q Meter injection voltage.
I\'m monitoring the voltage of a 0.02Ω source with an HP3400A at the end of a 15\" RG-58 cable. (no termination) Frequency is 1MHz.
Is this incorrect source and termination creating a voltage error?

I have the Q meter set at 20mV, and the HP3400A reads 21.5mV.
I\'m feel the HP3400A is accurate, at least according to a HP8640B and HP3330A. I don\'t know if the Q meter volt setting is wrong or if the short cable could cause that much error.

Mikek

 

[Lamont Cranston]

On Monday, October 24, 2022 at 6:02:33 PM UTC-5, Lamont Cranston wrote:

Measuring Q Meter injection voltage.
I\'m monitoring the voltage of a 0.02Ω source with an HP3400A at the end of a 15\" RG-58 cable. (no termination) Frequency is 1MHz.
Is this incorrect source and termination creating a voltage error?

I have the Q meter set at 20mV, and the HP3400A reads 21.5mV.
I\'m feel the HP3400A is accurate, at least according to a HP8640B and HP3330A. I don\'t know if the Q meter volt setting is wrong or if the short cable could cause that much error.

Mikek

I may have answered my own question, I shorted the cable to 12\" and lowered the frequency to 70kHz, the HP3400A still reads the same.
I think the error is in my Q meter. Adding a 50Ω feed thru termination at the HP3400A input makes no difference.
Still open to input.
Mikek

 

[John Larkin]

On Mon, 24 Oct 2022 16:02:29 -0700 (PDT), Lamont Cranston
<amdx62@gmail.com> wrote:

Measuring Q Meter injection voltage.
I\'m monitoring the voltage of a 0.02? source with an HP3400A at the end of a 15\" RG-58 cable. (no termination) Frequency is 1MHz.
Is this incorrect source and termination creating a voltage error?

I have the Q meter set at 20mV, and the HP3400A reads 21.5mV.
I\'m feel the HP3400A is accurate, at least according to a HP8640B and HP3330A. I don\'t know if the Q meter volt setting is wrong or if the short cable could cause that much error.

Mikek

I\'d expect the error at 1 MHz to be tiny, much smaller than the 7.5%
you see.

You could Spice it for the actual numbers.

 

[Ricky]

On Monday, October 24, 2022 at 7:11:54 PM UTC-4, Lamont Cranston wrote:

On Monday, October 24, 2022 at 6:02:33 PM UTC-5, Lamont Cranston wrote:
Measuring Q Meter injection voltage.
I\'m monitoring the voltage of a 0.02Ω source with an HP3400A at the end of a 15\" RG-58 cable. (no termination) Frequency is 1MHz.
Is this incorrect source and termination creating a voltage error?

I have the Q meter set at 20mV, and the HP3400A reads 21.5mV.
I\'m feel the HP3400A is accurate, at least according to a HP8640B and HP3330A. I don\'t know if the Q meter volt setting is wrong or if the short cable could cause that much error.

Mikek
I may have answered my own question, I shorted the cable to 12\" and lowered the frequency to 70kHz, the HP3400A still reads the same.
I think the error is in my Q meter. Adding a 50Ω feed thru termination at the HP3400A input makes no difference.
Still open to input.
Mikek

Because 50 ohms is so much larger than the 0.02 ohm source impedance, the source will drive the full output onto the cable. This voltage will run the length of the cable, and be reflected by the high impedance, with the two adding. So the load should see the driving voltage doubled. This reflection will run to the driver and, the driver appearing to be nearly a short, will have virtually no impact on the driving signal strength. The only trouble is, since the frequencies are low, you may not see any of this happen.

So if the Q meter is outputting 20 mV and the meter is reading 21.5 mV, that would make sense, since the impact of the reflection is greatly muted by the low frequency of the signal. It takes a lot less current to drive the voltage ramp of a 1 MHz signal than a faster one. Try the same measurement at 10 MHz, and 100 MHz. I would expect a higher frequency to produce a higher reflection.

--

Rick C.

- Get 1,000 miles of free Supercharging
- Tesla referral code - https://ts.la/richard11209

 

[Lamont Cranston]

On Monday, October 24, 2022 at 10:54:52 PM UTC-5, Ricky wrote:

On Monday, October 24, 2022 at 7:11:54 PM UTC-4, Lamont Cranston wrote:
On Monday, October 24, 2022 at 6:02:33 PM UTC-5, Lamont Cranston wrote:
Measuring Q Meter injection voltage.
I\'m monitoring the voltage of a 0.02Ω source with an HP3400A at the end of a 15\" RG-58 cable. (no termination) Frequency is 1MHz.
Is this incorrect source and termination creating a voltage error?

I have the Q meter set at 20mV, and the HP3400A reads 21.5mV.
I\'m feel the HP3400A is accurate, at least according to a HP8640B and HP3330A. I don\'t know if the Q meter volt setting is wrong or if the short cable could cause that much error.

Mikek
I may have answered my own question, I shorted the cable to 12\" and lowered the frequency to 70kHz, the HP3400A still reads the same.
I think the error is in my Q meter. Adding a 50Ω feed thru termination at the HP3400A input makes no difference.
Still open to input.
Mikek
Because 50 ohms is so much larger than the 0.02 ohm source impedance, the source will drive the full output onto the cable. This voltage will run the length of the cable, and be reflected by the high impedance, with the two adding. So the load should see the driving voltage doubled. This reflection will run to the driver and, the driver appearing to be nearly a short, will have virtually no impact on the driving signal strength. The only trouble is, since the frequencies are low, you may not see any of this happen.

So if the Q meter is outputting 20 mV and the meter is reading 21.5 mV, that would make sense, since the impact of the reflection is greatly muted by the low frequency of the signal. It takes a lot less current to drive the voltage ramp of a 1 MHz signal than a faster one. Try the same measurement at 10 MHz, and 100 MHz. I would expect a higher frequency to produce a higher reflection.

--

Rick C.

- Get 1,000 miles of free Supercharging
- Tesla referral code - https://ts.la/richard11209

I raised the frequency to 10MHz, the \'20mV\' signal increased to read 23.6mV on the HP3400A, installing a 50Ω termination dropped it to 23mV.
Putting a 1x scope probe on the HP3400A, the \'20mV\' measurement reads 21mV @1MHz.
Even the very shortest connection I can make to the HP3400A, it still reads 21mV. (less than 1 inch)
https://www.dropbox.com/s/eymw67eti8cbldl/Short%20connection%20to%20HP3400A..jpg?dl=0
At this point, I think the Q meter 1x multiplier setting is reading low.
Mikek