Lumped element model limitation

[tsp]

Can somebody tell me why the lumped element model breaks down when
actual circuit impedances are very low, or when the length of the wire
approaches the wavelength of the circuit's operating frequency?

 

[Don Kelly]

"tsp" <tspjor@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:8efbd3ef.0409232206.79cc2e2e@posting.google.com...

Can somebody tell me why the lumped element model breaks down when
actual circuit impedances are very low, or when the length of the wire
approaches the wavelength of the circuit's operating frequency?
---------

Lumped model circuit theory is a quasi-static approximation of field theory.
It works well when distances are considerably less than a quarter
wavelength. However, where it is valid -it is a lot easier than going to
more complex approaches. Below is a <list>(?) in order of complexity
Consider a 1 ft length of wire:
DC and low frequency-lumped model is a resistor.
Higher frequency- Inductance effects are measurable -lumped model OK
higher yet- both L and C lumped model works
Higher- Transmission line models as R, L and C must be considered
distributed- otherwise errors crop up
(example 100mile length of unloaded power transmission line will have about
a 5% higher voltage at the receiving end than at the sending end-lumped
model doesn't show this). However a lumped T or pi model can be used for a
specific line and is correct at the ends but not in the middle(10V at each
end of a 1/4 wavelength line and the mid-line voltage will be about 14V).
Higher yet and it is necessary to consider the line as a wave guide.
Beyond that -now you are not using lines- you are using antennae and
radiating .

As for the lumped model not being valid for low impedances- not true. The
breakdown may be that the model is not including all the factors which can
be ignored at higher impedance levels. For example-at Z=R=0.01 ohms an
ignored contact or meter resistance of 0.1 ohms can make measurements
meaningless. If R=100 ohms, the effect is negligible.

--
Don Kelly
dhky@peeshaw.ca
remove the urine to answer

 

[Roy McCammon]

tsp wrote:

Can somebody tell me why the lumped element model breaks down when
actual circuit impedances are very low,

I've never heard that.

or when the length of the wire approaches the
wavelength of the circuit's operating frequency?

Maxwell's equations are operative at all lengths
(ignoring qm). The question that really needs
to be answered is why to lumped models work
at all.




--
local optimization seldom leads to global optimization

my e-mail address is: <my first name> <my last name> AT mmm DOT com