GPO's per circuit, how many in latest regs?

[Geoff C]

If anybody knows with some confidence the number of GPO's per power cct in
Aus (Vic) according to latest wiring regs, I would appreciate it. A sparky
recently told me 14. This means 7 doubles. Is this correct? This is for
standard 16 amp fuses per cct. Also, how is the de-rating calculted if you
put one or more standard light fittings on a power cct. The sparky told me
there is a de-rating but could not recall the calcs from the regs.

 

[David]

On Tue, 11 Jan 2005 11:11:42 +0000, Geoff C wrote:

If anybody knows with some confidence the number of GPO's per power cct in
Aus (Vic) according to latest wiring regs, I would appreciate it. A sparky
recently told me 14. This means 7 doubles. Is this correct? This is for
standard 16 amp fuses per cct. Also, how is the de-rating calculted if you
put one or more standard light fittings on a power cct. The sparky told me
there is a de-rating but could not recall the calcs from the regs.

No limit under AS/NZS 3000:2000, (also no such thing as GPO anymore, they
are called sockect outlets). Under the old rules there were limits to
encourage more than one power circuit. In the old rules multiple outlets
were counted as one less than the number, thus doubles were only counted
as one.

The main requirement of AS/NZS 3000:2000 is that the installation
functions as required in a safe and expected way.

Also, the fuse or other protection device is to protect the circuit, which
includes the wiring to the socket outlets. Depending on the installation
method of the wiring, and the protective device you use, you can use 16A,
20A, or event 25A circuit breakers. You need to work this out using
AS3008, and is mainly related to the heat loss in the wiring. You also
need to work out the voltage drop in the conductors.

There is no derating for connecting a light to the circuit, but the wiring
to the light must be rated to suit the circuit breaker, (ie the same size
as run to the socket outlets). Normaly lights are run in lighter cable
which saves costs.

Note however that the total number of sockets outlets in a domestic
installation can have an influence on the maximum demand of the
installation.


David

 

[Phil Allison]

"David"

The main requirement of AS/NZS 3000:2000 is that the installation
functions as required in a safe and expected way.

Also, the fuse or other protection device is to protect the circuit, which
includes the wiring to the socket outlets. Depending on the installation
method of the wiring, and the protective device you use, you can use 16A,
20A, or event 25A circuit breakers.

** It sounds very unsafe to me to have a 25A breakers on a circuit that
supplies 10 amp rated socket outlets. The cables fitted to many appliances
( heaters etc) are not fused and rely on the 15 amp breaker in the supply to
protect them.

Or is this not in fact permitted ?



................ Phil

 

[David]

"Geoff C" <nos@nos.com> wrote in message news:41e3b46d$0$8338$afc38c87@news.optusnet.com.au...

If anybody knows with some confidence the number of GPO's per power cct in
Aus (Vic) according to latest wiring regs, I would appreciate it. A sparky
recently told me 14. This means 7 doubles. Is this correct? This is for
standard 16 amp fuses per cct. Also, how is the de-rating calculted if you
put one or more standard light fittings on a power cct. The sparky told me
there is a de-rating but could not recall the calcs from the regs.

Excuse the html, hopefully it will help with formatting.

AS/NZS 3018:2001 (Domestic electrical installations) requires the wiring for socket outlets to be a minimum of 2.5 sq mm unless more than 2300 mm above floor level (but only for appliances less than 150W or luminaires). Protective devices to be rated according to the total load and for protection of the wiring, specifically taking into account the temperature rise etc.

You can mix final sub-circuits and contain both lighting and power points. There is a guide for that in Appendix C, Table C1 of the Standard. The mixed circuit must be RCD protected.

Table C1 is too hard to reproduce here without knowing the conductor size you have. For a 2.5 sq mm conductor protected by a 16 A breaker the following applies:

Installation methods ii, iii, iv, v apply (see below)
Maximum number of points = 20
Contibution of each point, up to rating of circuit breaker
Lighting points = 0.5
Socket outlets = 1.0

So, you could have 12 lighting points (worth 6) and 10 socket outlets (worth 10) on one 16A breaker equipped 2.5 sq mm cabled mixed sub-circuit. Or, 15 socket outlets and 2 lighing points. So for general use, 7 doubles would be right with 4 or less lighting points.

This does not apply when a specific appliance or application is intended to be connected and the load can be estimated. For example where the socket outlets are run to a dishwasher or kitchen bench and it is estimated the load will be xA. You deduct xA from the 16A available and then use the above calc for the remainder. So if you assume (cough.. estimate) 10A is needed at one particular location then with 4 lighting points you can have 4 other GPOs on that mixed circuit.

Note that a double or other multiple outlet counts as the number of outlets it provides (so a four way is counted as four and a double as two) - see footnote (b) below.

For non-mixed circuits, generally two final sub-circuits must be provided, and a guide to the number of points per sub-circuit appears in Table 6.1 of the above standard.

To quote from Table 6.1 for socket outlets:

==========Load Breaker rating Cond size Inst Method Quantity

10A 16 2.5 ii, iii, iv, v 15
Socket 20 2.5 iii, iv, v Unlimited
Outlets 16 4.0 i, ii, iii, iv, v 15
20 4.0 ii, iii, iv, v Unlimited
25 4.0 iii, iv, v Unlimited
32 4.0 iv, v Unlimited

FOOTNOTES TO TABLE 6.1: (some deleted as irrelevant in this discussion)

(a) Installation methods:
I Completely surrounded by thermal insulation.
II Partially surrounded by thermal insulation.
III Enclosed in air.
IV Unenclosed in air.
V Buried underground in wiring enclosure.

(b) For the purpose of determining the number of points, a multiple combination of socket-outlets
shall be regarded as the same number of points as the number of integral
socket-outlets in the combination.
==========
This info provided in good faith but is not authoratative so get the standard(s) and research further. From my experience and contact with many different electricians and/or engineers, most 'sparkies' are now unable to follow AS/NZS3000 as it no longer tells them exactly how to do things and deals with issues requiring data far beyond their reach. AS/NZS3018 is more easily followed by the average sparkie as it has some prescriptive content.

In answer to a question from Phil elsewhere in this thread, over-current protection of devices plugged into the socket outlet is no longer considered, only protection of the installation. This places some product specific standards at odds with the wiring standards - some equipment is allowed to rely on the 'building protection' for over-current protection. So a 32A breaker equipped circuit is certainly at odds with this type of product safety requirement. As an example I haven't seen any pedestal cooling fans with fuses or circuit breakers (other than thermal fuses in motors) - a wiring fault is not supposed to happen (two independent fixings etc) according to the product standards AS/NZS60335-1 and 60335-2-80.

Hope this helps.
Dave.

 

[Geoff C]

"David" <dave@mail--swap.bpa.nu> wrote in
news:zr_Ed.114747$K7.61994@news-server.bigpond.net.au:

"Geoff C" <nos@nos.com> wrote in message
news:41e3b46d$0$8338$afc38c87@news.optusnet.com.au...
If anybody knows with some confidence the number of GPO's per power
cct in
Aus (Vic) according to latest wiring regs, I would appreciate it. A
sparky
recently told me 14. This means 7 doubles. Is this correct? This is
for
standard 16 amp fuses per cct. Also, how is the de-rating calculted
if
you
put one or more standard light fittings on a power cct. The sparky
told me
there is a de-rating but could not recall the calcs from the regs.

Excuse the html, hopefully it will help with formatting.

AS/NZS 3018:2001 (Domestic electrical installations) requires the
wiring for socket outlets to be a minimum of 2.5 sq mm unless more
than 2300 mm above floor level (but only for appliances less than 150W
or luminaires). Protective devices to be rated according to the total
load and for protection of the wiring, specifically taking into
account the temperature rise etc.

You can mix final sub-circuits and contain both lighting and power
points. There is a guide for that in Appendix C, Table C1 of the
Standard. The mixed circuit must be RCD protected.


------=_NextPart_000_01B0_01C4F89C.53B0D160--

Thanks for that David. I have one 16 amp 2.5 sqmm cct with 7 outlets so a
couple more will be OK.

 

[David]

"Geoff C" <nos@nos.com> wrote in message
news:41e49817$0$5058$afc38c87@news.optusnet.com.au...

"David" <dave@mail--swap.bpa.nu> wrote in
news:zr_Ed.114747$K7.61994@news-server.bigpond.net.au:

"Geoff C" <nos@nos.com> wrote in message
news:41e3b46d$0$8338$afc38c87@news.optusnet.com.au...
If anybody knows with some confidence the number of GPO's per power
cct in
Aus (Vic) according to latest wiring regs, I would appreciate it. A
sparky
recently told me 14. This means 7 doubles. Is this correct? This is
for
standard 16 amp fuses per cct. Also, how is the de-rating calculted
if
you
put one or more standard light fittings on a power cct. The sparky
told me
there is a de-rating but could not recall the calcs from the regs.

Excuse the html, hopefully it will help with formatting.

AS/NZS 3018:2001 (Domestic electrical installations) requires the
wiring for socket outlets to be a minimum of 2.5 sq mm unless more
than 2300 mm above floor level (but only for appliances less than 150W
or luminaires). Protective devices to be rated according to the total
load and for protection of the wiring, specifically taking into
account the temperature rise etc.

You can mix final sub-circuits and contain both lighting and power
points. There is a guide for that in Appendix C, Table C1 of the
Standard. The mixed circuit must be RCD protected.


------=_NextPart_000_01B0_01C4F89C.53B0D160--

Thanks for that David. I have one 16 amp 2.5 sqmm cct with 7 outlets so a
couple more will be OK.

Do you mean 7 existing single outlets or double outlets?

If singles then a few more will be OK. If doubles then only one more
single is allowed (a maximum of 15 for a non-mixed circuit).

Cheers
David.

 

[Phil Allison]

"David" <

Do you mean 7 existing single outlets or double outlets?

If singles then a few more will be OK. If doubles then only one more
single is allowed (a maximum of 15 for a non-mixed circuit).

** In the unit where I live - all the outlets and the fuse box were renewed
6 years back when the place was fully refurbished. There are 7 double
outlets and one single on the same circuit with a 20 amp breaker.

No RCD is installed.

But I have my own portable one in the workshop !




............... Phil

 

[Russ]

Phil Allison wrote:

"David"

Do you mean 7 existing single outlets or double outlets?

If singles then a few more will be OK. If doubles then only one more
single is allowed (a maximum of 15 for a non-mixed circuit).



** In the unit where I live - all the outlets and the fuse box were
renewed 6 years back when the place was fully refurbished. There are
7 double outlets and one single on the same circuit with a 20 amp
breaker.

No RCD is installed.

But I have my own portable one in the workshop !

Assuming you could find the first outlet on the circuit, I understand those
double GPOs with the inbuilt RCD will protect the downstream power points as
well. You might want to check this though.

 

[KLR]

On Wed, 12 Jan 2005 15:52:43 +1100, "Russ" <a@b.c> wrote:

Phil Allison wrote:
"David"

Do you mean 7 existing single outlets or double outlets?

If singles then a few more will be OK. If doubles then only one more
single is allowed (a maximum of 15 for a non-mixed circuit).



** In the unit where I live - all the outlets and the fuse box were
renewed 6 years back when the place was fully refurbished. There are
7 double outlets and one single on the same circuit with a 20 amp
breaker.

No RCD is installed.

But I have my own portable one in the workshop !

Assuming you could find the first outlet on the circuit, I understand those
double GPOs with the inbuilt RCD will protect the downstream power points as
well. You might want to check this though.


I believe that they do protect downstream sockets, but they would have

to have separate in and out terminals for the active and neutral at
least.

Although probably a very politically incorrect test procedure -
Putting one of these inbuilt RCD type sockets in circuit and
momentarily shorting together the neutral to earth on the OUTPUT side
and seeing if it trips would tend to prove if this "downstream
protection" exists or not.
failing that:
If the unit was renovated only 6 years ago, then there should be a
modern DIN rail switchboard, adding a DIN type RCD should be a very
easy job assuming there physically is room for it on the rail

--------------------------

(Im very surprised that there isnt one actually. Im told under QLD
law that they have to be fitted on all new buildings/renovations since
the early 1990's at least. According to a local electrician I used
about 2 years back - the light and power circuits must now be RCD
protected. The hot water system and stove/oven dont however

On real estate sales contracts (as of 3 months ago when I last was a
party to one) you must declare that there is/isnt an RCD fitted to the
property being sold.)

 

[Phil Allison]

"KLR"
Phil Allison wrote:

** In the unit where I live - all the outlets and the fuse box were
renewed 6 years back when the place was fully refurbished. There are
7 double outlets and one single on the same circuit with a 20 amp
breaker.

No RCD is installed.

But I have my own portable one in the workshop !

If the unit was renovated only 6 years ago, then there should be a
modern DIN rail switchboard, adding a DIN type RCD should be a very
easy job assuming there physically is room for it on the rail

** Yep - there is such a beast and room for something a lot bigger than
the present 80 amp switch.

Im very surprised that there isnt one actually. Im told under QLD
law that they have to be fitted on all new buildings/renovations since
the early 1990's at least.

** I rang the relevant authority in NSW and was told that since the place
only had no additional power circuits after the renovation there was no
compulsion to fit an RCD.

The uptake of RCDs is very slow in NSW - it make take centuries to get to
100%.

I understand that Qld has quite different regulations that mean RCDs must be
fitted when a premises changes ownership - this should mean that nearly
every premises has them installed before too long.




............... Phil

 

[Russ]

KLR wrote:

Although probably a very politically incorrect test procedure -
Putting one of these inbuilt RCD type sockets in circuit and
momentarily shorting together the neutral to earth on the OUTPUT side
and seeing if it trips would tend to prove if this "downstream
protection" exists or not.
failing that:

Assuming there is no load on the output of the RCD, would there actually be
any current between neutral & earth, or are you assuming there is a load?

 

[David]

On Wed, 12 Jan 2005 09:51:07 +1100, Phil Allison wrote:

"David"


The main requirement of AS/NZS 3000:2000 is that the installation
functions as required in a safe and expected way.

Also, the fuse or other protection device is to protect the circuit, which
includes the wiring to the socket outlets. Depending on the installation
method of the wiring, and the protective device you use, you can use 16A,
20A, or event 25A circuit breakers.



** It sounds very unsafe to me to have a 25A breakers on a circuit that
supplies 10 amp rated socket outlets. The cables fitted to many appliances
( heaters etc) are not fused and rely on the 15 amp breaker in the supply to
protect them.

Or is this not in fact permitted ?



............... Phil

The overcurrent protection is to protect the fixed wiring, not the
connected device, and is to protect against temperature rise in the
conductors. If the fixed wiring is installed in such a way that it can
carry 25A, there is no reason it unsafe to protect it with a 25A breaker.
Loads connected to 10A socket outlets should not exceed 10A if they are
fitted with a 10A plug. If they draw more then they will have a 15A or
higher rated plug. A heater rated at 2400 Watts (the maximum for a 10A
socket outlet), only uses 10A, and would be supplied with a 10A cord and
10A plug, and would not pose a safety issue from overload.

If two were connected to one circuit, the current would be 20A, and still
nothing would be overloaded. Connect three and the breaker would trip
eventually.

Note that this is only for overload, not short circuit. A short circuit to
either ground or to active - neutral will involve a much higher current,
and trip the breaker within seconds, before thermal damage can be caused
to the fixed wiring. Note that AS3000 does specify maximum earth
resistance, to ensure that an active to earth fault will trip the breaker.

Cheers
David

 

[Phil Allison]

"David"
Phil Allison

** It sounds very unsafe to me to have a 25A breakers on a circuit that
supplies 10 amp rated socket outlets. The cables fitted to many
appliances
( heaters etc) are not fused and rely on the 15 amp breaker in the supply
to
protect them.

Or is this not in fact permitted ?


The overcurrent protection is to protect the fixed wiring, not the
connected device, and is to protect against temperature rise in the
conductors. If the fixed wiring is installed in such a way that it can
carry 25A, there is no reason it unsafe to protect it with a 25A breaker.
Loads connected to 10A socket outlets should not exceed 10A if they are
fitted with a 10A plug. If they draw more then they will have a 15A or
higher rated plug. A heater rated at 2400 Watts (the maximum for a 10A
socket outlet), only uses 10A, and would be supplied with a 10A cord and
10A plug, and would not pose a safety issue from overload.

If two were connected to one circuit, the current would be 20A, and still
nothing would be overloaded. Connect three and the breaker would trip
eventually.

Note that this is only for overload, not short circuit. A short circuit to
either ground or to active - neutral will involve a much higher current,
and trip the breaker within seconds, before thermal damage can be caused
to the fixed wiring. Note that AS3000 does specify maximum earth
resistance, to ensure that an active to earth fault will trip the breaker.

** All very logical and nice - but avoids the issue I raised completely.

" The cables fitted to many appliances ( heaters etc) are not fused and
rely on the 15 amp breaker in the supply to
protect them. "

The "protect them" bit related to faults developing in the appliance which
have the effect of increasing the current draw above 10 amps - maybe up
to 20 or 24 amps. Enough to cause the cable and the plug to burn down but
no fuse to blow.

Then there are all those older multiway outlets that have no thermal
breaker - the attached cable is safeish to maybe 20 amps at most - and
then what - a nice domestic fire that burns babies ???

Domestic circuits have not been permitted to have fuse wires or breakers
with greater than 15 amp capacity since the year dot - when did the safety
issues change ??




............... Phil

 

[KLR]

On Wed, 12 Jan 2005 22:03:23 +1100, "Russ" <nomail@hotmail.com> wrote:

KLR wrote:

Although probably a very politically incorrect test procedure -
Putting one of these inbuilt RCD type sockets in circuit and
momentarily shorting together the neutral to earth on the OUTPUT side
and seeing if it trips would tend to prove if this "downstream
protection" exists or not.
failing that:

Assuming there is no load on the output of the RCD, would there actually be
any current between neutral & earth, or are you assuming there is a load?

OOPS - Didnt think of that one.

I would imagine there would have to be a load there as you suggest,
however on 2 occasions (in different installations) I have experienced
RCDs tripping under fault condition even with the main switch TURNED
OFF and no (Active) power entering the circuit


I didnt check it in detail as it wasnt in my premises, however both
would have been pretty modern setups that were built and wired during
the late 1980's

 

[KLR]

On Wed, 12 Jan 2005 09:51:07 +1100, "Phil Allison"
<philallison@tpg.com.au> wrote:

"David"


The main requirement of AS/NZS 3000:2000 is that the installation
functions as required in a safe and expected way.

Also, the fuse or other protection device is to protect the circuit, which
includes the wiring to the socket outlets. Depending on the installation
method of the wiring, and the protective device you use, you can use 16A,
20A, or event 25A circuit breakers.



** It sounds very unsafe to me to have a 25A breakers on a circuit that
supplies 10 amp rated socket outlets. The cables fitted to many appliances
( heaters etc) are not fused and rely on the 15 amp breaker in the supply to
protect them.

Or is this not in fact permitted ?

in the old days of the ceramic fuseholder - it was always 15 A fuse

wire in use (8a for lights) - at least in the 70s which is as far
back as I can remember.

(in QLD) - It seems normal in modern times to fit 20 or 25a breakers
onto each domestic power circuit. Had a look at the 15a circuit that
I had installed in 1997 by licensed electrician - and it has a 25a
breaker in there. Another I saw was in a friends 2 bed flat - where
there was one power circuit for the GPOs (except fridge) and a
separate power circuit that only went to the fridge socket (and didnt
go through the ELCB), The single 10a fridge socket had a 20a breaker
that I thought to be totallt illogical !! I would have thought a 10A
a lot more sensible choice for a dedicated single socket like that.

I also asked about this "higher amp ratings of modern installations"
some years back - and was told that the breakers have to act only as
"cable protection fuses" and values are dependant on the maximum amp
rating of the cable. seemed that 2.5mm square called for 20/25a and
1.0mm called for 10a.

It didnt seem that the cable run length and other factors were taken
into account though, and I must agree that it isnt a fully safe
system, that would lead to certain disaster if any appliance went
faulty and drew a current more than 10a but not high enough to trip
the 20/25a breaker !



The one system I do like though - for safety is the UK idea of having
a fuse (3AG or similar I think) fitted into the power plug of EACH
appliance, that way things with small current draw need only to have a
relatively small fuse in there, (can be fast or slo-blow as
appropriate) which will blow a lot earlier if the appliance goes into
overload, without risking any overcurrent damage to the wall socket,
plug pins or premises wiring

also wont kill everything else on that circuit too..



---------------


Of course you have the other extreme - russia - (220/380v) where
cheaply made 2 pin sockets (that look unsuitable for 10a use) are used
frequently - wired up by a cable I can only describe as a 0.5 MM
square cable that was wide spaced (like the 300ohm ribbon used in tv
aerials in the old days)

This would run out into the hallway where it went to the electricity
meter (exact same spinning disc types as used here in 70's and 80's).
I couldn't find fuses anywhere in this mess

Commercially made (and not very old) power boards and extension leads
that had no earth and wire that was WAY too thin for anything even
close to 10 a were in common use too and I nearly had a fit when
seeing them.



I could mention in very public areas lamp poles that seemed to be held
(more or less) upright by the overhead cables, substantial size supply
cables to buildings being draped over piles of cement blocks, or
thrown on roofs of houses and old falling down sheds for some
kilometres along a busy suburban rail line. but no one would believe
me

............... Phil

 

[Phil Allison]

"KLR"

** It sounds very unsafe to me to have a 25A breakers on a circuit that
supplies 10 amp rated socket outlets. The cables fitted to many appliances
( heaters etc) are not fused and rely on the 15 amp breaker in the supply
to
protect them.

Or is this not in fact permitted ?

in the old days of the ceramic fuseholder - it was always 15 A fuse
wire in use (8a for lights) - at least in the 70s which is as far
back as I can remember.

(in QLD) - It seems normal in modern times to fit 20 or 25a breakers
onto each domestic power circuit. Had a look at the 15a circuit that
I had installed in 1997 by licensed electrician - and it has a 25a
breaker in there. Another I saw was in a friends 2 bed flat - where
there was one power circuit for the GPOs (except fridge) and a
separate power circuit that only went to the fridge socket (and didnt
go through the ELCB), The single 10a fridge socket had a 20a breaker
that I thought to be totallt illogical !! I would have thought a 10A
a lot more sensible choice for a dedicated single socket like that.

I also asked about this "higher amp ratings of modern installations"
some years back - and was told that the breakers have to act only as
"cable protection fuses" and values are dependant on the maximum amp
rating of the cable. seemed that 2.5mm square called for 20/25a and
1.0mm called for 10a.

It didnt seem that the cable run length and other factors were taken
into account though, and I must agree that it isnt a fully safe
system, that would lead to certain disaster if any appliance went
faulty and drew a current more than 10a but not high enough to trip
the 20/25a breaker !

** No faulty electrical item is needed to create a dangerous situation -
merely the use of a common extension lead ( possibly 7.5 amp rated) with a
simple double adaptor on the end supplying two 10 amp loads, ie two 2400
watt room heaters.

Someone is playing funny buggers with the rules here - over fusing a
domestic circuit is inherently dangerous and one of the main causes of
domestic fires.



................ Phil

 

[David]

On Thu, 13 Jan 2005 01:55:44 +1000, KLR wrote:

On Wed, 12 Jan 2005 22:03:23 +1100, "Russ" <nomail@hotmail.com> wrote:

KLR wrote:

Although probably a very politically incorrect test procedure -
Putting one of these inbuilt RCD type sockets in circuit and
momentarily shorting together the neutral to earth on the OUTPUT side
and seeing if it trips would tend to prove if this "downstream
protection" exists or not.
failing that:

Assuming there is no load on the output of the RCD, would there actually be
any current between neutral & earth, or are you assuming there is a load?




OOPS - Didnt think of that one.

I would imagine there would have to be a load there as you suggest,
however on 2 occasions (in different installations) I have experienced
RCDs tripping under fault condition even with the main switch TURNED
OFF and no (Active) power entering the circuit


I didnt check it in detail as it wasnt in my premises, however both
would have been pretty modern setups that were built and wired during
the late 1980's

RCD's will normally trip if you short the neutral to earth on an RCD
protected circuit. This is because there is normally a voltage
differential between the neutral and earth due to load currents in that
circuit other circuits. When you short neutral to earth, there will often
be sufficient current (greater than 30mA) flow in the neutral to trip the
RCD, as there is no balancing current in the active. This will happen even
if there is no load in that particular circuit.

David

 

[David]

On Wed, 12 Jan 2005 23:41:20 +1100, Phil Allison wrote:

** All very logical and nice - but avoids the issue I raised completely.

" The cables fitted to many appliances ( heaters etc) are not fused and
rely on the 15 amp breaker in the supply to
protect them. "

The "protect them" bit related to faults developing in the appliance which
have the effect of increasing the current draw above 10 amps - maybe up
to 20 or 24 amps. Enough to cause the cable and the plug to burn down but
no fuse to blow.

This is a very unlikely case. High current devices such as heaters etc
would typically go open circuit in case of failure, or if the element did
short out partially, would burn out well before any wiring would overheat
dangerously. Other devices are required to have internal protection
against overload / fire as per AS/NZS3100 and other standards.

Then there are all those older multiway outlets that have no thermal
breaker - the attached cable is safeish to maybe 20 amps at most - and
then what - a nice domestic fire that burns babies ???

I never liked these, but people need some common sense with electricity.

Domestic circuits have not been permitted to have fuse wires or breakers
with greater than 15 amp capacity since the year dot - when did the safety
issues change ??

Where did you get this "fact" from Phil? Please provide a reference. The
old 1991 wiring rules clause 2.11.1.4 permitted 32A circuit breakers or
HRC fuses to protect final subcircuits having GPOs, or 25A revirable
fuses. There is no such limiting clause in AS/NZS3000:2000.

David

 

[Phil Allison]

"David"

** All very logical and nice - but avoids the issue I raised
completely.

" The cables fitted to many appliances ( heaters etc) are not fused and
rely on the 15 amp breaker in the supply to
protect them. "

The "protect them" bit related to faults developing in the appliance
which
have the effect of increasing the current draw above 10 amps - maybe
up
to 20 or 24 amps. Enough to cause the cable and the plug to burn down
but
no fuse to blow.

This is a very unlikely case. High current devices such as heaters etc
would typically go open circuit in case of failure, or if the element did
short out partially, would burn out well before any wiring would overheat
dangerously.

** Yawn - opinion presented as fact.

Then there are all those older multiway outlets that have no thermal
breaker - the attached cable is safeish to maybe 20 amps at most -
and
then what - a nice domestic fire that burns babies ???


I never liked these, but people need some common sense with electricity.

** Yawn - what patronising shite.

A simple double adaptor allows a common extension lead to be overloaded by
a factor of 3 times in current or about 15 - 20 times in heat dissipation.

That is ** damn** unsafe.

Domestic circuits have not been permitted to have fuse wires or breakers
with greater than 15 amp capacity since the year dot - when did the
safety
issues change ??


Where did you get this "fact" from Phil? Please provide a reference.

** Come down in the last shower did you ???

Domestic power circuit wire fuses were always rated at 15 amps - this goes
back to the 1930s and right up to very recently it seems. When cheap plug
in breakers arrived - 15 or 16 amp ones got used in lieu.

When did the safety issues change ???

Clearly they never have.



.................. Phil

 

[David]

On Thu, 13 Jan 2005 10:01:59 +1100, Phil Allison wrote:

"David"

** All very logical and nice - but avoids the issue I raised
completely.

" The cables fitted to many appliances ( heaters etc) are not fused
and
rely on the 15 amp breaker in the supply to
protect them. "

The "protect them" bit related to faults developing in the appliance
which
have the effect of increasing the current draw above 10 amps -
maybe up
to 20 or 24 amps. Enough to cause the cable and the plug to burn down
but
no fuse to blow.

This is a very unlikely case. High current devices such as heaters etc
would typically go open circuit in case of failure, or if the element
did short out partially, would burn out well before any wiring would
overheat dangerously.


** Yawn - opinion presented as fact.


Then there are all those older multiway outlets that have no thermal
breaker - the attached cable is safeish to maybe 20 amps at most -
and
then what - a nice domestic fire that burns babies ???


I never liked these, but people need some common sense with
electricity.


** Yawn - what patronising shite.

A simple double adaptor allows a common extension lead to be overloaded
by
a factor of 3 times in current or about 15 - 20 times in heat
dissipation.

That is ** damn** unsafe.


** Yawn - Phils

Clearly Phil, as you are resorting to insults, I know that you are wrong.
You really should have finished that Uni course, then you would know that
3 times current, would only result in a 9 times increase in power being
lost by the cables.

Domestic circuits have not been permitted to have fuse wires or
breakers
with greater than 15 amp capacity since the year dot - when did the
safety
issues change ??


Where did you get this "fact" from Phil? Please provide a reference.


** Come down in the last shower did you ???

No. I am fully qualified Engineer and fully licensed Electrical
contractor.

Domestic power circuit wire fuses were always rated at 15 amps - this
goes back to the 1930s and right up to very recently it seems. When
cheap plug in breakers arrived - 15 or 16 amp ones got used in lieu.

When did the safety issues change ???

Clearly they never have.

As I asked before, can you provide a reference for your "fact". As I
stated before which you deleted, the old 1991 wiring rules have allowed
up to 32A breakers for 10A socket outlets. This is a FACT, in the WIRING
RULES.

While it was common practice to use 16A rewireable fuses with 2.5mm2
cable, this was because it was normally the cheapest legal solution. Also,
the wiring rules treated those cheap plug in breaker the same as
rewireable fuses. If you spent more money, and installed a HRC fuse or
proper ciruit breaker, you could use up to 25A for 2.5mm2 cables,
depending on the installation method. If you wanted you could use 4mm2
cable, and 32A circuit breakers, but this was not in most electrician's
economic interests.

Your wild assumptions are incorrect. You don't have a degree or even an
electrical license, and obviously have no idea of the requirements of the
standards. Buy the standards and learn.

David