Bad Idea: Put 9V Flasher LED on top of 9V Battery??

N

NoMailPlease

Guest
I bought a 9V flasher LED and put it on a 9V battery. 5 days later, the
battery is dead. Did I just get a bad battery, or, should I have put a
resistor (or something) in the circuit?

All I wanna do is have a flashing LED. It was working great until the
battery got drained. If there are more components required to make this
thing last longer, can you please point me in the right direction?

Thanks
 
"NoMailPlease" <DoNotSendMe@AnyMail.OK> wrote in message
news:BE3Ac.733103$Pk3.657146@pd7tw1no...
I bought a 9V flasher LED and put it on a 9V battery. 5 days later, the
battery is dead. Did I just get a bad battery, or, should I have put a
resistor (or something) in the circuit?

All I wanna do is have a flashing LED. It was working great until the
battery got drained. If there are more components required to make this
thing last longer, can you please point me in the right direction?

Thanks


Well, if you have a 600 mAH battery, and your LED draws 20 mA, then
Click to expand...
you'll get 600/20 = 30 continuous hours' operation.

Apparently, you lucked out! :)

Cheers!
Rich
 
"Rich Grise" <null@example.net> wrote in message
news:aqcAc.28947$H65.20872@nwrddc02.gnilink.net...
"NoMailPlease" <DoNotSendMe@AnyMail.OK> wrote in message
news:BE3Ac.733103$Pk3.657146@pd7tw1no...
I bought a 9V flasher LED and put it on a 9V battery. 5 days
later, the
battery is dead. Did I just get a bad battery, or, should I have
put a
resistor (or something) in the circuit?

All I wanna do is have a flashing LED. It was working great until
the
battery got drained. If there are more components required to
make this
thing last longer, can you please point me in the right direction?

Thanks


Well, if you have a 600 mAH battery, and your LED draws 20 mA, then
you'll get 600/20 = 30 continuous hours' operation.

Apparently, you lucked out! :)

Cheers!
Rich
Click to expand...
The flasher must have a 25% duty cycle...

Somebody posted a link to am EDN 'fleapower' indicator that would work
for years. However, it only flashes once every 10 seconds, and that
for 20ms. Its a low battery indicator.

Regards,
Bob Monsen
 
You guys are breaking my heart. I thought I'd put this LED on top of the 9V
and it'd work for 6 months..

Now, is it even possible (with a better circuit) to make a LED flash (say
every 1-3 seconds) that would last for months using a 9V battery??

If I got a lower voltage/mA LED, would it be worth the trouble or would I
still be looking at a life of only a few days?

Also, I bought a long life Energizer 9V to replace the dollar store one that
only lasted 5 days. I'll let you know if the Energizer is worth 4 times the
price..

Thanks for all you help

"Robert C Monsen" <rcsurname@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:BgjAc.128479$Ly.47748@attbi_s01...
"Rich Grise" <null@example.net> wrote in message
news:aqcAc.28947$H65.20872@nwrddc02.gnilink.net...
"NoMailPlease" <DoNotSendMe@AnyMail.OK> wrote in message
news:BE3Ac.733103$Pk3.657146@pd7tw1no...
I bought a 9V flasher LED and put it on a 9V battery. 5 days
later, the
battery is dead. Did I just get a bad battery, or, should I have
put a
resistor (or something) in the circuit?

All I wanna do is have a flashing LED. It was working great until
the
battery got drained. If there are more components required to
make this
thing last longer, can you please point me in the right direction?

Thanks


Well, if you have a 600 mAH battery, and your LED draws 20 mA, then
you'll get 600/20 = 30 continuous hours' operation.

Apparently, you lucked out! :)

Cheers!
Rich



The flasher must have a 25% duty cycle...

Somebody posted a link to am EDN 'fleapower' indicator that would work
for years. However, it only flashes once every 10 seconds, and that
for 20ms. Its a low battery indicator.

Regards,
Bob Monsen
Click to expand...
 
"NoMailPlease" <DoNotSendMe@AnyMail.OK> wrote in message
news:b4sAc.757562$Pk3.666585@pd7tw1no...
You guys are breaking my heart. I thought I'd put this LED on top of the
9V
and it'd work for 6 months..

Now, is it even possible (with a better circuit) to make a LED flash (say
every 1-3 seconds) that would last for months using a 9V battery??
Click to expand...
You could try a 6 pack of AA's, but you would probly need some other
circuitry to control the flash time, duty cycle and current better. What is
the application?

If I got a lower voltage/mA LED, would it be worth the trouble or would I
still be looking at a life of only a few days?

Also, I bought a long life Energizer 9V to replace the dollar store one
that
only lasted 5 days. I'll let you know if the Energizer is worth 4 times
the
price..

Thanks for all you help
Click to expand...
I doubt it will last 4 times as long, but it's worth a try since you already
bought it. 9volt batteries are only rated for about 500mAH. A typical LED
uses 20mA. If you do the math, you can get an idea of what you would need.
Alkaline AA's are rated at about 2000mAH. Maybe it would run on 6volts? Have
you tried that?

Joe
 
I've always had a car alarm and in my new car I figured I'd save the $300
and just put a flashing LED on the dashboard. There was a blank knock-out
panel on the dash, so I bought a flashing LED and mounting grommet. I fed
the battery connector to the coin box and this is where I plug the LED into
a 9V battery.

The whole thing works great for at least 5 days until the battery dies. (I
leave it flashing 24 hours per day.) I've seen articles about attaching
flashing LEDs to the car battery, but given my tiny knowledge of
electronics, I'd rather keep this circuit separate.

My dream now, is to build a better circuit that would allow the flasher to
live for several weeks. I never knew that 9V batteries had such short
lives. If I were to create the most efficient LED flasher circuit possible,
would it be worth the trouble. Or, would I gain just a few more hours out
of the whole thing?

If it's worth the trouble, do you know of any plans to build a flashing LED
that runs on AA's, etc??

Thanks for all your help!

"Joe" <nuisancewildlife@nospamearthlink.net> wrote in message
news:W%HAc.5643$bs4.4229@newsread3.news.atl.earthlink.net...
"NoMailPlease" <DoNotSendMe@AnyMail.OK> wrote in message
news:b4sAc.757562$Pk3.666585@pd7tw1no...
You guys are breaking my heart. I thought I'd put this LED on top of
the
9V
and it'd work for 6 months..

Now, is it even possible (with a better circuit) to make a LED flash
(say
every 1-3 seconds) that would last for months using a 9V battery??

You could try a 6 pack of AA's, but you would probly need some other
circuitry to control the flash time, duty cycle and current better. What
is
the application?


If I got a lower voltage/mA LED, would it be worth the trouble or would
I
still be looking at a life of only a few days?

Also, I bought a long life Energizer 9V to replace the dollar store one
that
only lasted 5 days. I'll let you know if the Energizer is worth 4 times
the
price..

Thanks for all you help


I doubt it will last 4 times as long, but it's worth a try since you
already
bought it. 9volt batteries are only rated for about 500mAH. A typical LED
uses 20mA. If you do the math, you can get an idea of what you would need.
Alkaline AA's are rated at about 2000mAH. Maybe it would run on 6volts?
Have
you tried that?

Joe
Click to expand...
 
"NoMailPlease" <DoNotSendMe@AnyMail.OK> wrote in message
news:N3MAc.768306$Pk3.569221@pd7tw1no...
I've always had a car alarm and in my new car I figured I'd save the
$300
and just put a flashing LED on the dashboard. There was a blank
knock-out
panel on the dash, so I bought a flashing LED and mounting grommet.
I fed
the battery connector to the coin box and this is where I plug the
LED into
a 9V battery.

The whole thing works great for at least 5 days until the battery
dies. (I
leave it flashing 24 hours per day.) I've seen articles about
attaching
flashing LEDs to the car battery, but given my tiny knowledge of
electronics, I'd rather keep this circuit separate.

My dream now, is to build a better circuit that would allow the
flasher to
live for several weeks. I never knew that 9V batteries had such
short
lives. If I were to create the most efficient LED flasher circuit
possible,
would it be worth the trouble. Or, would I gain just a few more
hours out
of the whole thing?

If it's worth the trouble, do you know of any plans to build a
flashing LED
that runs on AA's, etc??

Thanks for all your help!
Click to expand...
You may want to consider tying into your car battery. You can get
cigarette lighter adapters, which will give you 12V. Use that to power
a 7809 voltage regulator (which you can get anywhere electronics parts
are sold, like Radio Shack, for example.) Use the output of the 7809
to power your flasher.

Your flasher will probably work with 12V with a 150 ohm resistor in
series; it's probably worth a try.

The other possibility is rechargable batteries.

Regards
Bob Monsen
 
That sounds alot safer. I tried using 2 AA batteries to power the flasher
LED and it works fine. I'm very interested to see how long the AAs work vs.
the 9V..

I also ran across a flashing circuit that's supposed to last a year at
http://www.discovercircuits.com/L/lite-flash.htm. If I keep going through
batteries or don't get brave enough to attach to the car battery, I might
just build it and see how it performs.




"Robert C Monsen" <rcsurname@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:p%MAc.71286$HG.63775@attbi_s53...
"NoMailPlease" <DoNotSendMe@AnyMail.OK> wrote in message
news:N3MAc.768306$Pk3.569221@pd7tw1no...
I've always had a car alarm and in my new car I figured I'd save the
$300
and just put a flashing LED on the dashboard. There was a blank
knock-out
panel on the dash, so I bought a flashing LED and mounting grommet.
I fed
the battery connector to the coin box and this is where I plug the
LED into
a 9V battery.

The whole thing works great for at least 5 days until the battery
dies. (I
leave it flashing 24 hours per day.) I've seen articles about
attaching
flashing LEDs to the car battery, but given my tiny knowledge of
electronics, I'd rather keep this circuit separate.

My dream now, is to build a better circuit that would allow the
flasher to
live for several weeks. I never knew that 9V batteries had such
short
lives. If I were to create the most efficient LED flasher circuit
possible,
would it be worth the trouble. Or, would I gain just a few more
hours out
of the whole thing?

If it's worth the trouble, do you know of any plans to build a
flashing LED
that runs on AA's, etc??

Thanks for all your help!


You may want to consider tying into your car battery. You can get
cigarette lighter adapters, which will give you 12V. Use that to power
a 7809 voltage regulator (which you can get anywhere electronics parts
are sold, like Radio Shack, for example.) Use the output of the 7809
to power your flasher.

Your flasher will probably work with 12V with a 150 ohm resistor in
series; it's probably worth a try.

The other possibility is rechargable batteries.

Regards
Bob Monsen
Click to expand...
 
"NoMailPlease" <DoNotSendMe@AnyMail.OK> wrote in message
news:KkNAc.769095$Pk3.59693@pd7tw1no...
That sounds alot safer. I tried using 2 AA batteries to power the
flasher
LED and it works fine. I'm very interested to see how long the AAs
work vs.
the 9V..

I also ran across a flashing circuit that's supposed to last a year
at
http://www.discovercircuits.com/L/lite-flash.htm. If I keep going
through
batteries or don't get brave enough to attach to the car battery, I
might
just build it and see how it performs.
Click to expand...
I like the second one. Its simple, but it will last for a long time.
If you use two duracell batteries, it should last well over a year.

"Robert C Monsen" <rcsurname@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:p%MAc.71286$HG.63775@attbi_s53...

"NoMailPlease" <DoNotSendMe@AnyMail.OK> wrote in message
news:N3MAc.768306$Pk3.569221@pd7tw1no...
I've always had a car alarm and in my new car I figured I'd save
the
$300
and just put a flashing LED on the dashboard. There was a blank
knock-out
panel on the dash, so I bought a flashing LED and mounting
grommet.
I fed
the battery connector to the coin box and this is where I plug
the
LED into
a 9V battery.

The whole thing works great for at least 5 days until the
battery
dies. (I
leave it flashing 24 hours per day.) I've seen articles about
attaching
flashing LEDs to the car battery, but given my tiny knowledge of
electronics, I'd rather keep this circuit separate.

My dream now, is to build a better circuit that would allow the
flasher to
live for several weeks. I never knew that 9V batteries had such
short
lives. If I were to create the most efficient LED flasher
circuit
possible,
would it be worth the trouble. Or, would I gain just a few more
hours out
of the whole thing?

If it's worth the trouble, do you know of any plans to build a
flashing LED
that runs on AA's, etc??

Thanks for all your help!


You may want to consider tying into your car battery. You can get
cigarette lighter adapters, which will give you 12V. Use that to
power
a 7809 voltage regulator (which you can get anywhere electronics
parts
are sold, like Radio Shack, for example.) Use the output of the
7809
to power your flasher.

Your flasher will probably work with 12V with a 150 ohm resistor
in
series; it's probably worth a try.

The other possibility is rechargable batteries.

Regards
Bob Monsen
Click to expand...
 
NoMailPlease wrote:
I also ran across a flashing circuit that's supposed to last a year at
http://www.discovercircuits.com/L/lite-flash.htm. If I keep going through
batteries or don't get brave enough to attach to the car battery, I might
just build it and see how it performs.
Click to expand...
Standard disclaimer: use at your own risk, etc.:
Because you mentioned that you were relatively inexperienced in electronics,
the expression, "attach it to the car battery" is a little scary. It
sounds like you might be thinking of attaching directly to the battery,
which requires both fusing and the knowledge of how to design and install
it safely (without risk of burning the car or yourself).

The right place to tie in is at the car's fuse block. That's the
distribution point for electrical power.

You'll want to find a circuit with a small-value fuse (e.g., 5 amp) that is
energized with the key off, and find a wire on the fused side of that
circuit (when the fuse is pulled, it's dead). Then you can just tap into
that wire using one of those 3M insulation displacement connectors (no
stripping, cutting or soldering). Voila! And you're protected against
accidental short circuits.

--
John Miller
Email address: domain, n4vu.com; username, jsm

In good speaking, should not the mind of the speaker know the truth of the
matter about which he is to speak?
-Plato
 
Umm, it all sounds so easy when an electrical engineer describes installing
the LED into the car's electrical system... With my sad grasp of
electronics, I'm gonna have to stick with the lame 9V battery powered
solution.

With the new Energizer battery, the LED has lasted over 5 days now. If I
get tired of replacing batteries, I'm going to get a hold of this LM3909
replacement: http://www.nteinc.com/specs/800to899/pdf/nte876.pdf. Their
datasheet says that it'll flash for upto a year on a C cell. I'm going to
use it to build this circuit
http://www.uoguelph.ca/~antoon/circ/ledflash.htm.

If the spec sheet is relatively true, I expect this thing to flash for at
least a few months.

Thanks for all the help you guys have given me for this lame little project!
I only wish that I'd taken some electronics courses in school. It all comes
back to haunt you I guess.

James
 
"NoMailPlease" <DoNotSendMe@AnyMail.OK> wrote in message
news:Vo7Bc.821017$Ig.532986@pd7tw2no...
Umm, it all sounds so easy when an electrical engineer describes
installing
the LED into the car's electrical system... With my sad grasp of
electronics, I'm gonna have to stick with the lame 9V battery
powered
solution.

With the new Energizer battery, the LED has lasted over 5 days now.
If I
get tired of replacing batteries, I'm going to get a hold of this
LM3909
replacement: http://www.nteinc.com/specs/800to899/pdf/nte876.pdf.
Their
datasheet says that it'll flash for upto a year on a C cell. I'm
going to
use it to build this circuit
http://www.uoguelph.ca/~antoon/circ/ledflash.htm.

If the spec sheet is relatively true, I expect this thing to flash
for at
least a few months.

Thanks for all the help you guys have given me for this lame little
project!
I only wish that I'd taken some electronics courses in school. It
all comes
back to haunt you I guess.

James
Click to expand...
Actually, last night, I just built the flasher specified here:

http://www.discovercircuits.com/PDF-FILES/3vledfs1.pdf

However, instead of a battery, I powered it using a 1F 5V
'supercapacitor'. Its been flashing for about 15 hrs now on a 5V
charge. If you get a solar panel from here:
http://www.allelectronics.com/cgi-bin/category.cgi?category=565&item=SPL-60&type=store,
and use it to charge the cap, I suspect the circuit will flash forever
without a battery at all...

Regards,
Bob Monsen
 
In article <b4sAc.757562$Pk3.666585@pd7tw1no>, NoMailPlease wrote:
You guys are breaking my heart. I thought I'd put this LED on top of the 9V
and it'd work for 6 months..

Now, is it even possible (with a better circuit) to make a LED flash (say
every 1-3 seconds) that would last for months using a 9V battery??
Click to expand...
There are LEDs that achieve what used to be "normal LED brightness"
(that of older red GaAsP on GaAs LEDs at 20 mA) at a milliamp or less.
Better versions of green LEDs with wavelength in the 520's of nanometers
get that bright at .3 to .5 mA. 600 mAH with a 10% duty cycle means .5 mA
10% of the time for 12,000 hours, or about a year and a half.

- Don Klipstein (don@misty.com)
 
In article <W%HAc.5643$bs4.4229@newsread3.news.atl.earthlink.net>, Joe wrote:
"NoMailPlease" <DoNotSendMe@AnyMail.OK> wrote in message
news:b4sAc.757562$Pk3.666585@pd7tw1no...
You guys are breaking my heart. I thought I'd put this LED on top of the
9V and it'd work for 6 months..

Now, is it even possible (with a better circuit) to make a LED flash (say
every 1-3 seconds) that would last for months using a 9V battery??

You could try a 6 pack of AA's, but you would probly need some other
circuitry to control the flash time, duty cycle and current better. What is
the application?


If I got a lower voltage/mA LED, would it be worth the trouble or would I
still be looking at a life of only a few days?

Also, I bought a long life Energizer 9V to replace the dollar store one
that only lasted 5 days. I'll let you know if the Energizer is worth 4
times the price..

I doubt it will last 4 times as long, but it's worth a try since you already
bought it. 9volt batteries are only rated for about 500mAH. A typical LED
uses 20mA. If you do the math, you can get an idea of what you would need.
Alkaline AA's are rated at about 2000mAH. Maybe it would run on 6volts? Have
you tried that?
Click to expand...
Dollar store batteries are not alkaline, and so are worth maybe around
200 mAH or maybe even less...

And I want to keep reminding people that there are now a large and
increasing number of brands, part numbers, etc. of LEDs that achieve at 3
mA or less, even as low as .3 mA, a brightness that most LEDs of 20-25
years ago (and some current models with such old technology) required 20
mA to achieve.

- Don Klipstein (don@misty.com)
 
Well, well. Guess what happened today? The Energizer 9V stopped flashing
after 5 days. Here's the sad part. The dollar store battery lasted just
as long as the Energizer! Makes me wonder why I spent $4 on the Energizer.
The dollar store battery brand was named "TuffGuy" (I'm serious) just in
case you wanna stock up..

I'm still waiting for the flasher on top of the 2 AA batteries to die. I'm
curious to find out if they last longer than 5 days. We're at day 3 now.

I like those .3 mA LEDs you're talking about. Do you or Bob have any idea
what kind of mA the LM3909 style flasher ICs use up? That solar cell idea
is pretty cool.

Thanks


"Don Klipstein" <don@manx.misty.com> wrote in message
news:slrncdc6vk.evu.don@manx.misty.com...
In article <W%HAc.5643$bs4.4229@newsread3.news.atl.earthlink.net>, Joe
wrote:

"NoMailPlease" <DoNotSendMe@AnyMail.OK> wrote in message
news:b4sAc.757562$Pk3.666585@pd7tw1no...
You guys are breaking my heart. I thought I'd put this LED on top of
the
9V and it'd work for 6 months..

Now, is it even possible (with a better circuit) to make a LED flash
(say
every 1-3 seconds) that would last for months using a 9V battery??

You could try a 6 pack of AA's, but you would probly need some other
circuitry to control the flash time, duty cycle and current better. What
is
the application?


If I got a lower voltage/mA LED, would it be worth the trouble or would
I
still be looking at a life of only a few days?

Also, I bought a long life Energizer 9V to replace the dollar store one
that only lasted 5 days. I'll let you know if the Energizer is worth 4
times the price..

I doubt it will last 4 times as long, but it's worth a try since you
already
bought it. 9volt batteries are only rated for about 500mAH. A typical
LED
uses 20mA. If you do the math, you can get an idea of what you would
need.
Alkaline AA's are rated at about 2000mAH. Maybe it would run on 6volts?
Have
you tried that?

Dollar store batteries are not alkaline, and so are worth maybe around
200 mAH or maybe even less...

And I want to keep reminding people that there are now a large and
increasing number of brands, part numbers, etc. of LEDs that achieve at 3
mA or less, even as low as .3 mA, a brightness that most LEDs of 20-25
years ago (and some current models with such old technology) required 20
mA to achieve.

- Don Klipstein (don@misty.com)
Click to expand...
 
"NoMailPlease" <DoNotSendMe@AnyMail.OK> wrote in message
news:EgrBc.828601$oR5.450637@pd7tw3no...
Well, well. Guess what happened today? The Energizer 9V stopped
flashing
after 5 days. Here's the sad part. The dollar store battery
lasted just
as long as the Energizer! Makes me wonder why I spent $4 on the
Energizer.
The dollar store battery brand was named "TuffGuy" (I'm serious)
just in
case you wanna stock up..
Click to expand...
If they are both alkaline, then there isn't going to be much
difference in their capacity. I tried to find non-alkaline batteries
at a dollar store recently; no luck. The store I visited only had
alkalines. I was looking for AAs, and for a buck, I got 4 of them.
Cheaper than costco.

I'm still waiting for the flasher on top of the 2 AA batteries to
die. I'm
curious to find out if they last longer than 5 days. We're at day 3
now.
Click to expand...
Suprisingly, AA batteries can supply current much longer than 9V
batteries. An alkaline duracell AA battery has almost 3 amp-hours, as
opposed to an alkaline duracell 9V, which has between 500 and 700 mA
hours. The total energy in an AA is less, due to the lower voltage.

I like those .3 mA LEDs you're talking about. Do you or Bob have
any idea
what kind of mA the LM3909 style flasher ICs use up? That solar
cell idea
is pretty cool.
Click to expand...
The LED is still flashing using the capacitor. I hooked up that 3V
solar cell, and it seems to have kept up up the voltage.

And, the LED isn't one of Don's fancy LEDs. Its just a blue "high
brightness" led bought at Halted in San Jose last year. A high
brightness LED that takes 3mA instead of 30mA would last 10x.

Regards, and please, start posting replies at the bottom of the
message... :)

Bob Monsen
 
John Miller wrote:

Standard disclaimer: use at your own risk, etc.:
Because you mentioned that you were relatively inexperienced in electronics,
the expression, "attach it to the car battery" is a little scary. It
sounds like you might be thinking of attaching directly to the battery,
which requires both fusing and the knowledge of how to design and install
it safely (without risk of burning the car or yourself).

The right place to tie in is at the car's fuse block. That's the
distribution point for electrical power.

You'll want to find a circuit with a small-value fuse (e.g., 5 amp) that is
energized with the key off, and find a wire on the fused side of that
circuit (when the fuse is pulled, it's dead). Then you can just tap into
that wire using one of those 3M insulation displacement connectors (no
stripping, cutting or soldering). Voila! And you're protected against
accidental short circuits.
Click to expand...

Yep, that's about how I would do it. But if you are scared to do the
installation yourself, have your car shop do it for you. Takes only 5
min so their time is a lot cheaper than a new car if you get it wrong...

IIRC, that sort of dummy burglar alarms are even commercially available
(so you are not the first to think about that). Whether they would scare
off a professional car thief is a different matter.

If you want to learn more about electronics, a real car burglar alarm
would be a nice project to start with. Some simple circuits come to
mind:

a) Somebody entering a car or driving it would cause movement. A
pendulum could be used to detect that. Circuit is very simple.
Disadvantage: Usually some kids find out quickly that shaking the car
causes the alarm to go off, and use it to annoy the neighbours.

b) A car ignition uses high current, causing the voltage at the car
battery to drop. This can be detected electronically. Not too
complicated, and probably quite tamper-proof.

c) Detect opening of the doors, using the switches for the internal
light. Very simple, but no real obstacle for professionals.

d) Detect the presence of humans inside the car by ultrasound. Circuit
is a bit more involved, an can sometimes cause false alarm after
temperature fluctuations.

Have a look at the electronics section of your local library for a book
on the subject. You may also be able to get such a system in kit form
from an electronics dealer.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Welcome to EDABoard.com

Sponsor

Back
Top